The best deals on hotels near Shelter Island School in Shelter Island, NY.

Access unmatched hotel rates and frequent flash deals on rooms.

Save up to 70% when booking as a group. Select 9+ rooms to get started.

Top 24 Hotels Near Shelter Island School
33 N Ferry Rd Shelter Island, NY 11964



The Harbor Front Inn

209 Front St Greenport, New York

This useful location means Shelter Island School is an easy drive from The Harbor Front Inn, allowing for a smooth start to the day.

The Harbor Front Inn often presents arrivals with locally inspired décor, complimentary refreshments, and warm boutique-style greetings. Accommodations typically highlight stylish décor, artisanal details, and spa-style bathrooms for a boutique-oriented guest retreat. Facilities may showcase locally sourced dining, curated lounges, and stylish bars for a polished boutique guest impression.

Accommodations often feature Wi-Fi, yoga mats, breakfast options, and laundry service, creating consistency in boutique travel routines.

  Call (855) 234-2997 to book with an agent.
  6.3 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$133.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Zey Hotel

439 Main Street Greenport, New York

The benefit of a uncomplicated drive to Shelter Island School makes Zey Hotel into a great hub before the main experience begins.

At Zey Hotel, guests are often welcomed with curated furnishings, artisanal details, and staff providing personal attention. Rooms may include curated furnishings, premium linens, and boutique bathrooms that create a polished and personalized impression. Amenities typically feature eclectic interiors, artisanal cafés, and cocktail lounges that reflect boutique hospitality and style.

A visit may highlight complimentary Wi-Fi, bike rentals, EV charging, and laundry support, offering boutique practicality and balance.

  Call (855) 233-0132 to book with an agent.
  6.4 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$360.00

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

1400 Silvermere Rd Greenport, New York

From Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows, Shelter Island School is a simple drive, a feature that makes the entire area feel more accessible.

Arrivals at Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows may present vending machines, compact desk service, and exterior room entries that reinforce daily routines. Each guest room may feature compact seating, cable access, and Wi-Fi, ensuring clear consistency for travelers during short stays. Shared spaces may include vending access, compact lobbies, and laundry facilities that reinforce reliable daily travel routines.

Guests may encounter Wi-Fi, vending corners, compact coffee service, and parking, reinforcing simple daily consistency for travelers.

  Call (855) 233-0132 to book with an agent.
  6.5 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$311.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

The Shoals Suites and Slips

61600 Main Rd Southold, New York

From The Shoals Suites and Slips, the uncomplicated run to Shelter Island School avoids complex roads to save time, making travel easy.

Guests at The Shoals Suites and Slips may encounter eclectic décor, complimentary lobby coffee, and boutique-style reception experiences. Guest rooms often feature artisanal décor, plush bedding, and curated minibars that contribute to a boutique-focused guest stay. Shared spaces may present intimate lounges, farm-to-table restaurants, and curated cafés for a personalized boutique retreat.

Guests may encounter self-serve markets, complimentary Wi-Fi, laundry facilities, and pet allowances, sustaining flexible guest routines.

  Call (855) 236-8982 to book with an agent.
  7.8 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$182.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Sound View Greenport

58775 County Rd. 48 Greenport, New York

In Shelter Island, Sound View Greenport is situated an easy drive from Shelter Island School, a spot that provides a simple commute.

Sound View Greenport may present a stylish reception with professional staff, elegant lobby décor, and complimentary infused water. Rooms often showcase elegant furnishings, plush bedding, and in-room coffee or tea makers that enhance the impression of upscale comfort. Property amenities often feature a full-service spa, upscale dining, and polished common areas designed to reflect a luxury experience.

Accommodations may include wellness facilities, refined dining, valet parking, and Wi-Fi, supporting sophistication across guest needs.

  Call (855) 233-7850 to book with an agent.
  8.1 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$123.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Wainscott Woods Retreat

380 Montauk Hwy Wainscott, New York

This sensible location permits Wainscott Woods Retreat to provide a convenient yet peaceful setting before the easy drive to Shelter Island School.

Wainscott Woods Retreat often provides quick check-in, parking close to the entrance, and a simple lobby space focused on practical convenience. Accommodations may provide compact seating, rainfall showers, and tasteful décor, reinforcing a simple yet polished overnight stay. Shared spaces may provide coin-operated laundries, vending access, and compact business areas that help travelers stay productive.

Guests may enjoy Wi-Fi, compact breakfast service, vending access, and laundry support, maintaining reliable daily routines away from home.

  Call (855) 235-0725 to book with an agent.
  13.4 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$952.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Bridgehampton Inn

2266 Main St Bridgehampton, New York

This practical role as a base makes Bridgehampton Inn a key hub for those visiting Shelter Island School from out of town.

Bridgehampton Inn often greets guests with warm staff welcomes, artisanal décor, and complimentary refreshments for a boutique entry. Guest rooms may feature eclectic décor, premium bedding, and curated minibars that reflect a stylish boutique orientation. Facilities often highlight co-working corners, eclectic décor, and stylish bars that create a boutique-oriented guest experience.

A stay often provides Wi-Fi, boutique breakfast, laundry service, and yoga mats, balancing boutique individuality with convenience.

  Call (855) 234-5074 to book with an agent.
  13.7 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$299.00

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

The Maidstone

207 Main Street East Hampton, New York

The uncomplicated regional drive from The Maidstone to Shelter Island School in Shelter Island means guests a simple and reliable way to get to their destination.

At The Maidstone, the arrival experience typically blends upscale finishes, attentive staff, and professional luggage service. Guest rooms may provide refined interiors, premium bedding, and spa-style bathrooms designed with upscale finishes for guest relaxation. Facilities may include stylish bars, fine dining restaurants, and outdoor terraces that emphasize a polished and sophisticated setting.

Guests may enjoy elegant lounges, spa services, cocktail bars, and Wi-Fi, balancing upscale indulgence with modern digital convenience.

  Call (855) 234-2997 to book with an agent.
  15.3 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$267.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Journey East Hampton

490 Pantigo Road East Hampton, New York

As a sensible base, Journey East Hampton is a core aspect that enhances the freedom of the guest.

Arrivals at Journey East Hampton often feature elegant lobby details, concierge presence, and complimentary courtesies for guests. Accommodations typically highlight stylish décor, plush bedding, and minibars that support a polished and sophisticated overnight stay. Public areas typically showcase refined lounges, spa-inspired facilities, and upscale dining options for a polished luxury orientation.

A visit typically highlights premium bedding, wellness areas, refined dining, and Wi-Fi, ensuring flexibility across travel routines.

  Call (855) 235-6136 to book with an agent.
  16.4 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$176.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

The Roundtree Amagansett

273 Main Street Amagansett, New York

Shelter Island School is a simple commute from The Roundtree Amagansett, a layout that ensures travel plans are always straightforward.

At The Roundtree Amagansett, arrivals may include refined décor, professional concierge guidance, and complimentary infused water in the lobby. Rooms may feature elegant interiors, premium linens, and in-room espresso machines that add convenience to a luxury-focused atmosphere. Amenities may include a heated pool, spa services, and fine dining venues that contribute to a refined and comfortable guest impression.

A stay may feature spa-style spaces, cocktail bars, valet services, and Wi-Fi, sustaining polished ease throughout refined guest stays.

  Call (855) 233-7850 to book with an agent.
  17.2 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$535.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Southampton Inn

91 Hill Street Southampton, New York

From Southampton Inn, the easy regional drive to Shelter Island School makes it a sensible hub for an easy trip for your visit.

At Southampton Inn, arrivals may feature boutique furnishings, cozy seating, and staff focused on creating a personalized welcome. Accommodations often include unique furnishings, artisanal design details, and spa-style bathrooms for a refined guest retreat. Amenities may include artisanal lounges, curated cafés, and intimate dining venues that emphasize a creative boutique impression.

Accommodations may present bike rentals, complimentary Wi-Fi, family breakfast, and laundry support, supporting consistent routines.

  Call (855) 233-7850 to book with an agent.
  20.4 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$200.00

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

The Atlantic Hotel

1655 County Rd. 39 Southampton, New York

From the moment you arrive at The Atlantic Hotel, Shelter Island School is an easy regional drive for easy access.

At The Atlantic Hotel, arrivals may highlight an efficient desk, vending machines, and accessible parking to support predictable travel rhythm. Rooms may highlight curated décor, premium bedding, and Wi-Fi, offering a balance of style and utility for traveling guests. Facilities often highlight vending machines, modest lobbies, and laundry areas that emphasize simple and reliable daily guest routines.

A stay often features Wi-Fi, guest laundry, vending machines, and modest breakfast, sustaining clarity and convenience for travelers.

  Call (855) 235-6136 to book with an agent.
  21.5 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$123.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

The Bentley Hotel Southampton

161 Hills Station Rd Southampton, New York

The journey from The Bentley Hotel Southampton to Shelter Island School is a direct drive, a perk that adds to the overall sense of convenience.

Guests at The Bentley Hotel Southampton may encounter a no-frills reception, modest lobby seating, and on-site parking for straightforward transitions. Each guest room often features hardwood floors, blackout curtains, and in-room coffee, giving travelers privacy and daily convenience. Public areas typically include breakfast counters, vending access, and compact seating that create practical support during visits.

A visit may include Wi-Fi, modest breakfast, vending access, and guest laundry, maintaining straightforward convenience for all guests.

  Call (855) 234-7135 to book with an agent.
  22.2 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$129.00

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Sea Haven Resort Motel

52 Longview Road Southampton, New York

From Sea Haven Resort Motel, Shelter Island School is a simple commute, a choice that makes the entire area feel more accessible.

Sea Haven Resort Motel often provides modest lobbies, vending areas, and exterior parking that help maintain practical clarity for arrivals daily. Accommodations often highlight microwaves, modest bedding, and mini-fridges, reinforcing functional focus for budget-conscious guests. Facilities often feature modest lobbies, vending corners, and breakfast spaces that sustain straightforward consistency during visits.

A visit may include Wi-Fi, exterior parking, vending access, and guest laundry, sustaining straightforward balance across short visits.

  Call (855) 234-2997 to book with an agent.
  22.5 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$118.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Canoe Place Inn and Cottages

239 East Montauk Hwy Hampton Bays, New York

Because Canoe Place Inn and Cottages is a convenient base, guests can utilize a moment of fresh air before their drive to Shelter Island School.

Canoe Place Inn and Cottages often greets guests with stylish interiors, courteous doorman service, and polished reception staff for a luxury welcome. Guest rooms often present refined furnishings, plush bedding, and bathrooms finished with marble or stone to reflect upscale standards. Shared facilities often feature polished lobbies, upscale restaurants, and wellness spaces that highlight a sophisticated guest retreat.

Accommodations often provide plush bedding, refined dining, spa lounges, and Wi-Fi, shaping a sophisticated yet balanced experience.

  Call (855) 233-0132 to book with an agent.
  24.9 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$553.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Saybrook Point Resort & Marina

2 Bridge St Old Saybrook, Connecticut

For guests in the Shelter Island area, Saybrook Point Resort & Marina is a practical base, a location that supports an efficient and enjoyable itinerary.

Guests at Saybrook Point Resort & Marina often find eclectic interiors, warm greetings, and artisanal touches that create a boutique-style experience. Rooms may highlight premium linens, locally inspired décor, and curated minibars that provide added boutique-style convenience. Shared spaces may include artisanal cafés, curated cocktail bars, and eclectic lounges that reflect boutique character and comfort.

A visit often includes Wi-Fi, self-serve markets, laundry facilities, and EV charging, reflecting boutique convenience for modern stays.

  Call (855) 234-2997 to book with an agent.
  25.2 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$309.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Pier Blue Inn Old Saybrook - Essex

1430 Boston Post Rd Old Saybrook, Connecticut

This convenient base helps Pier Blue Inn Old Saybrook - Essex guests get more connected to the Shelter Island area while keeping Shelter Island School accessible.

Pier Blue Inn Old Saybrook - Essex typically features practical front-desk service, self-serve beverages, and parking options aimed at easy, reliable arrivals. Guest rooms typically include plush bedding, streaming-enabled TVs, and climate control, providing both rest and entertainment options. Shared spaces may present vending corners, modest lobbies, and laundry rooms that reinforce straightforward consistency for travelers.

Guests may encounter Wi-Fi, compact breakfast areas, vending machines, and parking, sustaining clear routines across budget accommodations.

  Call (855) 235-6136 to book with an agent.
  26.5 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$69.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Hampton Bays Hotel on Main

2 West Montauk Hwy Hampton Bays, New York

For travelers who value a sensible starting point, Hampton Bays Hotel on Main is a convenient base for reaching Shelter Island School with ease.

Arrivals at Hampton Bays Hotel on Main may present a simple reception, complimentary parking, and vending access that emphasize day-to-day practicality. Accommodations may highlight compact layouts, ergonomic seating, and Wi-Fi, supporting comfort and productivity for each guest routine. Facilities often provide vending access, compact breakfast areas, and laundry spaces that maintain clarity and reliability for guests.

A stay often highlights Wi-Fi, vending access, modest breakfast, and guest laundries, reinforcing practical balance during daily travel.

  Call (855) 234-5074 to book with an agent.
  26.6 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$127.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook

1750 Boston Post Rd Old Saybrook, Connecticut

In Shelter Island, Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook's role as a convenient base remains a key asset for visitors who value easy travel.

Econo reception zones commonly include clear counters and short queue lanes, streamlining peak-time check-ins for faster flow. Standard guest rooms feature a clear desk, a coffee maker, a mini-fridge and in-room Wi-Fi to keep quick meals and device work convenient. The lobby seating is arranged near outlets and market corners so device charging and quick snacks happen without extra searching or steps.

Free Wi-Fi, hot breakfast, a fitness area, meeting space, vending and on-site laundry ensure brief visits keep routines intact and easy.

  Call (855) 234-2997 to book with an agent.
  26.7 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$79.48

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Waters Edge Resort & Spa

1525 Boston Post Road Westbrook, Connecticut

For travelers who value a sensible starting point, Waters Edge Resort & Spa is a sensible base for reaching Shelter Island School with ease.

Guests at Waters Edge Resort & Spa may encounter a sophisticated lobby with luggage assistance, refined seating, and complimentary coffee or tea. Accommodations may include polished décor, premium bedding, and minibars that contribute to a refined and comfortable guest experience. Property amenities may present refined lounges, cocktail bars, and spa-inspired spaces that support a polished luxury experience.

Guests may encounter wellness facilities, cocktail bars, valet support, and Wi-Fi, reinforcing rhythm within polished travel settings.

  Call (855) 234-2997 to book with an agent.
  26.9 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$229.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook

37 Spencer Plain Rd Old Saybrook, Connecticut

Shelter Island School is an easy regional drive from Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook, a layout that ensures travel logistics are always straightforward.

Murals and bold design elements in Super 8 lobbies reflect the brand’s modern refresh, creating memorable yet functional first looks. Guest rooms supply ergonomic chairs, large desks, and Wi-Fi, letting professionals remain productive while away from their offices. Fitness centers featuring cardio gear, weights, and stretching mats help travelers sustain personal health routines reliably.

Connectivity with Wi-Fi, complimentary breakfast, and vending areas aligns with fitness centers and parking, simplifying daily needs.

  Call (855) 236-8982 to book with an agent.
  27.1 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$59.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Gurneys Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

290 Old Montauk Highway Montauk, New York

The benefit of using Gurneys Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa as a sensible base renders it into a great anchor point before the main experience.

Arrivals at Gurneys Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa often feature elegant reception areas, attentive staff, and concierge support for a polished introduction. Rooms typically offer stylish interiors, plush linens, and spa-style bathrooms that highlight a polished and sophisticated impression. Common areas typically offer upscale dining options, elegant lounges, and fitness spaces designed to emphasize refined hospitality.

A visit may include refined interiors, spa-inspired services, fine dining, and Wi-Fi, supporting balance across leisure and business.

  Call (855) 239-4019 to book with an agent.
  27.6 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$289.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Aqua by American Beech - Adults Only

15 Bay Ave Riverhead, New York

A key planning advantage of Aqua by American Beech - Adults Only in Shelter Island is its role as a practical base with Shelter Island School within driving reach.

Aqua by American Beech - Adults Only often highlights efficient check-in, readily available parking, and a compact lobby to keep arrival steps clear and simple. Rooms often include rainfall showers, hardwood accents, and modest seating, reinforcing a practical yet stylish guest environment. Shared spaces typically feature modest lobbies, vending machines, and breakfast rooms that help sustain functional daily guest routines.

Accommodations may present Wi-Fi, continental breakfast, vending machines, and laundry support, helping sustain reliable routines daily.

  Call (855) 234-2997 to book with an agent.
  27.6 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$274.80

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Liberty Inn

55 Springbrook Road Old Saybrook, Connecticut

The benefit of using Liberty Inn as a practical base renders it into a great anchor point before the main experience.

At Liberty Inn, arrivals may include a modest front desk, quick parking access, and self-serve coffee for a low-friction check-in. Each guest room may feature premium linens, climate control, and blackout curtains, ensuring rest and comfort throughout overnight stays. Facilities may highlight vending corners, guest laundries, and compact seating zones that reinforce practical ease for each visit.

A visit may offer Wi-Fi, modest breakfast, vending corners, and parking, creating consistent travel support for budget-conscious guests.

  Call (855) 234-7135 to book with an agent.
  28.6 miles from Shelter Island School

Starting at

$64.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms