The best deals on hotels near HAY Harbor Golf Club in Fishers Island, NY.
Access unmatched hotel rates and frequent flash deals on rooms.
Save up to 70% when booking as a group. Select 9+ rooms to get started.
Top 24 Hotels Near HAY Harbor Golf Club
Ettrick Ave Fishers Island, NY
Hilltop Express Inn
Guests at Hilltop Express Inn can enjoy HAY Harbor Golf Club being an easy drive as a defining feature of a well-located stay.
Hilltop Express Inn typically includes an efficient counter, self-serve coffee, and nearby parking stalls to support reliable travel flow. Each guest room may include compact seating, climate control, and premium bedding, supporting comfort and consistency across stays. Facilities often include vending machines, laundry access, and compact breakfast spaces that sustain everyday convenience for travelers.
Accommodations may include Wi-Fi, guest laundry, breakfast spaces, and parking, helping visitors sustain reliable balance across trips.
Hampton Inn Groton
For a trip to the area, Hampton Inn Groton's role as a convenient base is an essential part of its convenience.
Community tables throughout Hampton Inn lobbies support connection, helping colleagues or companions coordinate travel plans together. Every guest room includes microwaves, coffee makers, and refrigerators, letting guests handle meals and refreshments with everyday convenience. Fitness studios with resistance machines, mats, and cardio options allow guests to maintain routines that support health and clarity.
Pet services, hot breakfast, business centers, indoor pools, and complimentary internet ensure balance across both work and leisure travel.
Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa
Because Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa is a sensible base, guests can readily make the easy regional drive to HAY Harbor Golf Club.
Grab-and-go markets placed near reception at Marriott ensure guests can secure essentials without detours after a long journey. Suites include lounge seating, spacious layouts, and large flat-screen TVs, creating relaxation zones that extend beyond the bed. The pool space includes loungers and towel service, providing a balanced mix of relaxation and family-friendly amenities during downtime.
Concierge service, event spaces, and Wi-Fi combine with dining and valet parking, helping travelers balance professional and leisure goals.
Rodeway Inn Groton - New London
Within the region, Rodeway Inn Groton - New London functions as a practical base, a fact that highlights its strategic placement.
Design elements at Rodeway Inn are straightforward — neutral colors, simple tilework, and overhead lighting support utility-first flow. Every guest room includes a hair dryer, bath linens, and basic storage, helping guests maintain their routines while away from home. Business centers provide internet-connected computers and basic print services, offering support for quick tasks and light productivity.
Each stay includes breakfast service, coin laundry, guest parking, vending machines, cable TV, and climate control in all rooms.
Motel 6 Groton CT—Casinos Nearby
This convenient base helps Motel 6 Groton CT—Casinos Nearby guests become more connected to the Fishers Island area while keeping HAY Harbor Golf Club accessible.
Motel 6 pairs courtesy coffee with functional reception, signaling hospitality while ensuring arrivals complete essentials without delay. Guest rooms feature private bathrooms with amenities like towels and toiletries, covering consistent self-care needs across multiple nights. Guest laundries locate detergent dispensers beside machines, letting travelers handle chores in one stop before evening plans resume.
With free morning coffee by the lobby, Wi-Fi access, vending, and parking, mornings begin smoothly and travel days stay predictable.
Ramada by Wyndham Groton / Mystic
Guests at Ramada by Wyndham Groton / Mystic can appreciate it as a sensible base, with HAY Harbor Golf Club an easy regional drive away.
Modernized décor and spacious layouts at Ramada lobbies create refreshed identity cues while reinforcing functional orientation. Each guest room offers sofa chairs, televisions, and charging stations, combining entertainment with relaxation and convenience. Fitness centers featuring treadmills, free weights, and stretching mats help travelers maintain balance while away from home.
Meeting rooms, business services, and Wi-Fi pair with restaurants and parking, supporting professional gatherings seamlessly.
Holiday Inn New London - Mystic Area by IHG
For a stay that relies on regional driving, Holiday Inn New London - Mystic Area by IHG offers a sensible base for the easy drive to HAY Harbor Golf Club.
Holiday Inn & Suites reception areas remain brightly lit and well staffed, ensuring arrivals move smoothly at all times of day. All guest rooms contain plush beds, blackout curtains, and quiet HVAC systems, ensuring travelers achieve restorative rest consistently. Lobby spaces with communal tables, lounge chairs, and natural light create dependable orientation points and social interaction.
Meeting facilities, free Wi-Fi, and breakfast buffets join with business centers and parking, providing dependable setups for all guests.
Super 8 by Wyndham Groton
In the Fishers Island region, Super 8 by Wyndham Groton's role as a practical base lets guests move in a way that feels natural and easy.
Reception desks at Super 8 are always visible from entry, helping both new and returning travelers orient easily on arrival. Guest rooms highlight comfortable beds, blackout drapes, and quiet HVAC systems, ensuring rest is consistent across property visits. Breakfast setups with cereals, coffee, and hot selections provide day-start clarity, ensuring routines stay simple for all travelers.
Complimentary breakfast, Wi-Fi, and pet accommodations pair with laundry and parking, creating dependable comfort for longer stays.
Hilton Garden Inn Mystic / Groton
The journey from Hilton Garden Inn Mystic / Groton to HAY Harbor Golf Club is a direct drive, a benefit that adds to the overall sense of convenience.
Sofa groupings inside Hilton Garden Inn receptions create intuitive rest points, allowing families to regroup calmly on arrival. Every guest room provides televisions, sofa seating, and blackout drapes, blending entertainment ease with spaces designed for rest. Lobbies with sofa seating, natural light, and bar adjacency provide comfortable social areas that foster guest interaction.
Business facilities, complimentary internet, breakfast service, indoor pools, and parking ensure consistent ease for work-focused guests.
Flagship Inn & Suites
In Fishers Island, Flagship Inn & Suites serves as a practical base, placing HAY Harbor Golf Club an easy regional drive away.
Arrivals at Flagship Inn & Suites may feature modest lobby furnishings, complimentary parking, and vending services for budget-friendly arrivals. Guest rooms often feature Wi-Fi, hardwood accents, and streaming-enabled TVs, offering both connection and entertainment while away. Shared spaces typically highlight breakfast counters, vending stations, and modest seating that maintain balance across daily routines.
A visit may highlight Wi-Fi, vending access, modest breakfast, and guest laundries, giving travelers consistent routines during stays.
Gold Star Inn & Suites
As a sensible base, Gold Star Inn & Suites is a core aspect that enhances the freedom of the guest.
Gold Star Inn & Suites often highlights compact front-desk setups, parking close to entry points, and vending machines to support quick check-in. Accommodations may provide curated décor, premium linens, and compact layouts, delivering balance and comfort for traveling guests. Facilities may present guest laundries, vending areas, and compact lobbies that reinforce clear and practical routines during visits.
Guests may enjoy Wi-Fi, compact breakfast corners, vending machines, and laundry support, reinforcing practicality across overnight visits.
Hyatt Place Mystic
When travel in the Fishers Island area is a factor, Hyatt Place Mystic's position as a practical base is a key benefit.
Lobby bars at Hyatt Place are visible from reception, creating relaxed hubs where travelers can unwind with drinks and light snacks. Guest rooms are fitted with coffee machines, mini-fridges, and blackout curtains, ensuring daily convenience and uninterrupted rest. Bars with visible counters, comfortable seating, and table service provide relaxed hubs where travelers can unwind and recharge.
Free breakfast, fitness centers, and meeting spaces connect with Wi-Fi and parking, keeping routines manageable and convenient.
Holiday Inn Express Mystic by IHG
Guests at Holiday Inn Express Mystic by IHG can utilize it as a practical base, a perk that adds a relaxing touch to the stay.
Markets in Holiday Inn Express hotels remain open 24/7, helping travelers secure late-night meals or quick daytime snacks with ease. All guest rooms include branded bath products, showers, and soft linens, ensuring reliable refreshment during every hotel visit. Pools surrounded by loungers, towel stations, and umbrellas give guests versatile recreation spaces for family-friendly relaxation.
Complimentary breakfast, fitness rooms, and Wi-Fi link with pools and laundry, making routines balanced and stress-free consistently.
Howard Johnson by Wyndham Mystic
In the Fishers Island area, Howard Johnson by Wyndham Mystic serves as a sensible base, which renders travel easy.
With lobby vending for drinks and quick bites, Howard Johnson bridges hunger gaps from transit, making first minutes on site easier. Guest rooms with sofa beds in some suites expand sleeping options, giving groups a practical way to spread out at night comfortably. The bar or lounge at select properties offers simple cocktails or beer service, enabling relaxed meetups without leaving the hotel.
Between breakfast service, Wi-Fi, and a lobby market for essentials, mornings feel organized and gaps don’t derail the day’s plans.
Hilton Mystic
For a trip to the area, Hilton Mystic's location as a practical base is a foundational component of the guest journey.
At Hilton, visible reception counters and clear signage help orient first-time travelers quickly and reduce stress on arrival. Guest rooms combine Serenity Beds, blackout curtains, and climate control, ensuring restful nights and refreshed mornings reliably. In the breakfast area, fruit, waffles, and hot coffee support travelers by creating consistent rituals that simplify morning routines.
With 24/7 markets, complimentary Wi-Fi, dining venues, and pet-friendly policies, Hilton simplifies travel while ensuring consistency.
Mystic River Hotel & Suites Near Casinos
The hotel's spot as a sensible base gives Mystic River Hotel & Suites Near Casinos guests a easy way to engage with the surrounding area.
At Mystic River Hotel & Suites Near Casinos, arrivals may present straightforward reception, basic lobby seating, and nearby parking aimed at travel consistency. Rooms typically include plush bedding, climate control, and blackout curtains, reinforcing privacy and comfort for restful overnight stays. Public areas may include vending access, breakfast rooms, and coin-operated laundry that emphasize straightforward convenience daily.
A stay may provide Wi-Fi, breakfast service, vending areas, and laundry rooms, sustaining clear and consistent routines in budget hotels.
Hampton Inn & Suites Mystic
As a convenient base, Hampton Inn & Suites Mystic is a core element that supports a flexible and relaxed visit.
Bright décor and modern design in Hampton Inn receptions create welcoming impressions that support orientation clarity for arrivals. Suites feature rainfall showers, premium toiletries, and spacious vanities, providing guests elevated refreshment during their stay. Meeting rooms with audiovisual gear, flexible seating, and internet access provide practical spaces for group collaboration and focus.
Complimentary breakfast, self-parking, Wi-Fi connectivity, fitness rooms, and outdoor pools deliver reliability for varied travel patterns.
Best Western Mystic Hotel
The uncomplicated regional drive from Best Western Mystic Hotel to HAY Harbor Golf Club in Fishers Island ensures guests have a pleasant option for their daily travel.
At roadside and suburban sites, Best Western keeps drop zones marked under canopy, making unloads predictable before vehicles proceed onward. All guest rooms may include mini-fridges and microwaves, so quick meals and late snacks remain convenient without leaving the room. Fitness rooms feature mirrors, mats, and space for stretches, supporting quick warm-ups or end-of-day resets that keep balance consistent.
From airport transfers where offered, parking, Wi-Fi, and luggage holds, movement and timing link smoothly between check-in and first activities.
Residence Inn by Marriott Mystic Groton
Guests at Residence Inn by Marriott Mystic Groton can count on it as a sensible base for the easy regional drive to HAY Harbor Golf Club.
Complimentary hot breakfast buffets at Residence Inn deliver reliable morning structure, ensuring guests feel supported daily. Every guest room features blackout curtains, plush bedding, and adjustable climate control, creating restful environments for deeper sleep. Business areas with flexible meeting tables, presentation screens, and reliable internet support collaboration across group stays.
Complimentary Wi-Fi, hot breakfast, outdoor pools, business centers, and fitness facilities ensure every stay remains balanced and dependable.
Spark by Hilton Mystic Groton
This practical function as a base is a defining feature of Spark by Hilton Mystic Groton, as it makes the stay both simple and enjoyable.
Hilton emphasizes ritual through coffee service and infused water, reliable details that ensure arrivals feel familiar and comfortable. Suites highlight soaking tubs, soft robes, and bright lighting, creating indulgent rituals that refresh guests during every stay. The fitness space offering bikes, resistance equipment, and cardio machines allows guests to maintain balance and energy reliably.
Amenities include valet parking, breakfast buffets, indoor pools, and meeting rooms, giving guests balance between work and leisure.
HomeTowne Studios by Red Roof Mystic - New London
For guests in the Fishers Island area, HomeTowne Studios by Red Roof Mystic - New London is a practical base, a spot that supports a relaxed and easy schedule.
Guests at HomeTowne Studios by Red Roof Mystic - New London may encounter efficient desk service, vending access, and on-site parking that emphasize predictable arrivals. Each guest room may highlight compact desks, ergonomic seating, and Wi-Fi, supporting productivity and ease during travel routines. Shared spaces often feature vending machines, modest lobbies, and compact breakfast spaces that help guests maintain simple routines.
Accommodations often present Wi-Fi, guest laundries, modest breakfast, and vending access, maintaining straightforward guest routines.
Red Roof Inn Mystic - New London
HAY Harbor Golf Club is within driving reach from Red Roof Inn Mystic - New London, a setup that ensures travel logistics are never a concern.
The aroma of fresh coffee provides a simple sensory welcome at Red Roof Inn, helping guests feel at ease from the moment they step inside. Guest rooms are designed with ample, conveniently located power outlets, making it easy for travelers to charge all their devices at once. Ample free parking, with space for larger vehicles, is a key benefit that provides clarity and removes a common travel hassle and expense.
From free local calls and Wi-Fi for business to a pool for fun, the hotel's amenities cater to a wide spectrum of traveler needs.
Clarion Inn New London - Mystic
For guests in the Fishers Island region, Clarion Inn New London - Mystic is a sensible base, a location that makes for a well-planned visit.
At the desk, Clarion can point guests to shuttle pickups where available, clarifying transfers before keys and directions are in hand. Every guest room offers reliable Wi-Fi and a clear TV layout, so navigation checks and shows fill small gaps without friction on tight schedules. Breakfast areas arrange coffee urns, cereal bars, pastries, and some hot items at labeled stations, giving mornings clarity before itineraries begin.
With airport shuttles at some properties, Wi-Fi, breakfast, and guest laundry, transfers connect smoothly and mornings launch on time.
Regency Inn & Suites New London Mystic
The hotel's spot as a sensible base gives Regency Inn & Suites New London Mystic guests a easy option for their regional commute.
Regency Inn & Suites New London Mystic typically offers practical front desk help, complimentary parking, and compact lobby space that supports budget arrivals. Guest rooms often include hardwood finishes, rainfall showers, and tasteful décor, creating a setting that balances comfort and style. Facilities may provide modest seating zones, vending areas, and guest laundries that support both comfort and practicality in travel.
A visit may feature Wi-Fi, compact breakfast counters, vending machines, and laundry access, supporting daily travel balance reliably.
Book as a group & pay separately.
Lowest Group Rate Guaranteed.
HAY Harbor Golf Club Local Area Guide
HAY Harbor Golf Club offers a premier golfing experience on the picturesque Fishers Island. This guide is designed for visiting golfers, providing essential information to help you plan your trip and maximize your enjoyment of the course and the surrounding area. Navigate your way from arrival to the final putt with insights on local amenities, dining, and practical tips for a seamless golf getaway. Get ready to experience world-class golf with stunning coastal views. We'll cover everything from the best routes to the club, where to find comfortable lodging, and how to make the most of your time on and off the greens. Prepare for a memorable outing tailored to the unique charm of Fishers Island.
Area contextNeighborhood Overview – HAY Harbor Golf Club (Fishers Island, NY)
Nestled on the eastern tip of Fishers Island, HAY Harbor Golf Club is situated in a unique maritime environment. Access to Fishers Island is primarily by ferry from New London, Connecticut, or Orient Point, New York. The island itself is characterized by rolling hills, coastal bluffs, and a serene, relatively undeveloped landscape.
Approaching the club involves arriving on the island via ferry and then navigating local roads. Given the island's size and limited vehicle traffic, cycling or walking are popular modes of transport once you've reached your accommodation. Parking at the club is generally ample and convenient for those arriving by car, with dedicated spaces for members and guests.
The nearest major airport is Tweed New Haven Regional Airport (Tweed-New Haven) in Connecticut, approximately a 45-minute drive from the New London ferry terminal, plus the ferry journey. Alternatively, Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP) is a drive to the Orient Point ferry. It's crucial to plan your ferry schedule carefully, as sailings can be impacted by weather and are less frequent than mainland transport. Allow ample time for ferry travel and connections to ensure a relaxed arrival before your tee time.
Lodging contextWhere to Stay Near HAY Harbor Golf Club
Lodging options on Fishers Island are somewhat limited and often booked well in advance, especially during peak golf season. Many visitors opt for vacation rentals or charming inns scattered across the island. These accommodations provide a more immersive experience of island life and are generally a short drive or bike ride from HAY Harbor Golf Club.
Given the island's scale, most accommodations are within a few miles of the golf club, making it convenient to access. It’s highly recommended to secure your lodging as early as possible, particularly if you’re visiting for a specific tournament or during summer months. Consider locations that offer easy access to both the golf club and ferry terminals.
Booking strategies should focus on early reservations and checking availability for different types of stays, from single rooms to entire homes for a foursome. Some hotels and rental agencies on the mainland near ferry terminals also serve as viable options if island lodging is unavailable, though this adds significant travel time each day. Utilize map views to understand proximity to ferry docks and the golf course itself.
View nearby hotels Quick Plan EssentialsQuick-Plan Overview
- Arrive via ferry from New London, CT or Orient Point, NY, followed by a short drive or bike ride.
- Allow extra time for ferry boarding and travel; check schedules in advance.
- Enjoy the island's natural beauty with a walk or bike ride between rounds.
- Explore local seafood shacks or enjoy a cozy meal at a village restaurant.
- Recharge at your lodging or a quiet island cafe after a day on the course.
Game Day Flow
Check-In & Warm-Up
Plan to arrive at HAY Harbor Golf Club at least 45-60 minutes before your scheduled tee time. This allows ample time to disembark your ferry, travel to the club, check in at the pro shop, and prepare for your round. Take advantage of the club's practice facilities to get a feel for the greens and fairways.
Familiarize yourself with the course layout and any specific local rules before heading to the first tee. The pro shop staff can provide valuable insights into course conditions and any play considerations for the day. This buffer time ensures a relaxed start, free from the rush of last-minute preparations.
Utilize the driving range and putting green to warm up your swing and get a sense of the club's turf. This preparatory phase is crucial for setting a positive tone for your game. Enjoy the serene island atmosphere as you transition from travel mode to golf mode.
Consider a light snack or beverage from the clubhouse to fuel your round. Staying hydrated and energized is key to maintaining focus throughout your game. The aim is to be fully ready and composed when it's time to play your first shot.
Confirm your group's readiness and review your strategy one last time. The pro shop is the central hub for all pre-game logistics and inquiries.
Mid-Day Regroup
Following your initial nine holes, take a moment to regroup at the clubhouse or designated halfway house if available. This break is an opportunity to refresh, discuss the front nine, and make any necessary adjustments to your game plan for the back nine. Many golfers find this pause essential for sustained performance.
Enjoy a quick lunch or a refreshing beverage to refuel. The club's dining facilities offer a chance to relax and socialize with your playing partners. It’s also a good time to check on any messages or briefly connect with those not on the course.
Observe the changing wind patterns or sun position as they might affect play in the afternoon. These environmental shifts can be significant on a coastal course like HAY Harbor. Understanding these nuances can provide a strategic advantage.
This mid-game pause is more than just a break; it’s a strategic reset. It allows players to re-center their focus and approach the latter half of the round with renewed energy and a clear mind. Embrace the island pace during this interval.
Take this time to mentally prepare for the challenges ahead, ensuring you’re ready to tackle the remaining holes with confidence.
Wrap-Up & Departure
After completing your round at HAY Harbor Golf Club, take time to properly conclude your golfing experience. Return your clubs, settle any outstanding accounts at the pro shop, and enjoy a final beverage or meal at the clubhouse. This is a great time to reflect on the day’s play and enjoy the club’s ambiance.
If you’re departing the island the same day, factor in sufficient time to return to your ferry terminal. Allow for potential delays, especially during peak travel times or if weather conditions are a factor. A relaxed departure contributes to the overall positive experience.
Consider purchasing any desired souvenirs or club merchandise as a memento of your visit. The pro shop often has unique items reflecting the club's identity and the island’s charm. These make for great keepsakes or gifts for fellow golf enthusiasts.
For those staying longer, plan your next activity or relaxation period. Whether it’s exploring more of Fishers Island or simply unwinding, ensure a smooth transition from the golf course. The island offers numerous quiet spots for post-golf leisure.
Ensure all personal belongings are gathered before leaving the club premises. A thorough check prevents any forgotten items and ensures a clean exit.
Things to Do Near HAY Harbor Golf Club
Walkable
Fishers Island Ferry Terminal
The heart of island connectivity, the ferry terminal serves as the primary gateway for visitors arriving by sea. It's a bustling point where islanders and tourists alike transition between the mainland and the tranquil shores of Fishers Island. Close proximity to the golf club means a seamless arrival and departure experience for many.
Beyond its practical function, the terminal area offers a glimpse into island life. You'll find small shops and places to grab a quick bite, perfect for a pre- or post-round snack. The scenic views of the water from the docks provide a pleasant introduction to the island's natural beauty.
It's a convenient spot to arrange transportation or simply enjoy the coastal atmosphere before heading to HAY Harbor. The rhythm of the ferries dictates a portion of the island's daily cadence, making the terminal a central hub of activity.
Fishers Island, NY · On siteFishers Island General Store
A cornerstone of the island community, the Fishers Island General Store is more than just a place to buy provisions; it’s a social hub. Visitors can find a variety of essentials, from snacks and beverages to local souvenirs, making it a convenient stop before or after a round of golf. It offers a taste of local commerce and island living.
The store often stocks items catering to both residents and seasonal visitors, including beach gear, local crafts, and everyday necessities. Grabbing a quick lunch or a picnic item here is a popular choice for those looking to enjoy the island’s scenic spots. Its central location makes it easily accessible.
Engaging with the friendly staff provides a personal touch and insight into the island’s character. It’s a reliable spot to pick up anything you might have forgotten for your day at HAY Harbor or to find a unique memento of your trip.
Island Center, Fishers Island, NY · 0.5 mi5–15 Minutes Away
Fishers Island Lighthouse
Standing sentinel on the island's easternmost point, the Fishers Island Lighthouse offers a picturesque landmark and a glimpse into maritime history. While access to the lighthouse itself might be restricted, the surrounding area provides stunning panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean and Long Island Sound. It's a beautiful spot for a contemplative walk or to appreciate the island's rugged coastline.
The drive to the lighthouse is part of the experience, winding through scenic island roads that showcase the unique topography and natural beauty. This area is often less populated, offering a sense of peaceful seclusion. Keep an eye out for local wildlife and the dramatic coastal flora.
Visiting this iconic structure provides a different perspective on the island's charm, away from the fairways of HAY Harbor. It's an ideal location for photography enthusiasts and those seeking a moment of quiet reflection amidst dramatic natural scenery. The sea breeze and expansive horizons are truly invigorating.
East End, Fishers Island, NY · 3.0 miIsabella Beach
Isabella Beach is one of Fishers Island's gems, offering a serene stretch of shoreline perfect for relaxation and enjoying coastal vistas. Whether you’re looking for a place to unwind after a challenging round at HAY Harbor or simply want to experience the island's natural beauty, this beach provides a tranquil escape. The gentle waves and sandy shores are inviting.
The beach is ideal for a leisurely stroll, picnicking, or simply soaking up the sun. Its location on the south shore means it often catches the sun throughout the day, making it a pleasant spot regardless of the time. Pack some refreshments from the General Store for a perfect beachside break.
Accessing Isabella Beach is part of the adventure, often involving navigating charming island roads. The relatively undeveloped nature of Fishers Island means that beaches like Isabella retain a natural, uncrowded feel, offering a genuine retreat from the everyday. It’s a perfect counterpoint to the focused intensity of golf.
South Shore, Fishers Island, NY · 2.5 miBeyond the Event: Beyond the immediate vicinity of HAY Harbor Golf Club, Fishers Island offers a range of quiet natural attractions. Explore more of its secluded beaches, scenic overlooks, and charming village areas. The island’s limited development ensures that outdoor recreation and natural beauty are always within reach. Consider renting a bicycle to fully explore the island’s winding roads and discover hidden coves and vistas.
Dining & nightlifeFood & Drink Near HAY Harbor Golf Club
Inside & Adjacent
HAY Harbor Golf Club Dining Room
The dining room at HAY Harbor Golf Club offers a convenient and refined option for golfers looking to enjoy a meal without leaving the club premises. With potential views overlooking the course, it provides a pleasant atmosphere for breakfast, lunch, or post-round refreshments. The menu typically features a selection of classic dishes suitable for a golf club setting.
It's the perfect spot for a quick bite between nines or a more leisurely meal after completing your round. The focus here is on providing a comfortable dining experience that complements your day of golf. Enjoying a meal here means maximizing your time on the island and minimizing travel.
The ambiance is generally relaxed yet sophisticated, catering to the club's clientele. Expect attentive service and a menu that aims to satisfy the appetites of golfers. It’s an integral part of the overall HAY Harbor experience, offering both sustenance and a place to socialize.
HAY Harbor Golf Club, Fishers Island, NY · On siteThe Pequot Inn Restaurant
The Pequot Inn Restaurant is a well-regarded establishment on Fishers Island, known for offering a taste of local flavor in a welcoming setting. It serves as a popular gathering spot for both island residents and visitors, providing a relaxed environment to enjoy well-prepared meals. Its proximity to the golf club makes it an accessible choice for post-game dining or a meal before heading to the ferry.
The menu often highlights fresh, seasonal ingredients, with a particular emphasis on seafood, a staple in this coastal community. Diners can expect a menu that balances familiar favorites with dishes that reflect the island’s culinary heritage. It’s a place where you can savor the essence of Fishers Island cuisine.
Whether you're seeking a casual lunch or a more formal dinner, The Pequot Inn Restaurant aims to provide a satisfying experience. The island atmosphere pervades the dining space, making it an ideal location to unwind and reflect on your day’s adventures, including your time on the links.
Fishers Island, NY · 0.7 miNearby Gathering Spots
Fishers Island General Store Cafe
While primarily a general store, the cafe section offers a casual and convenient spot for light meals, snacks, and beverages. It’s a quintessential island experience, allowing visitors to grab a coffee, a sandwich, or some local baked goods in a relaxed, unpretentious atmosphere. This is a perfect place for a quick refuel after a game or while exploring the island.
The cafe’s informal setting makes it ideal for families or groups looking for an easygoing meal. You can pick up picnic supplies here to enjoy at one of the island’s scenic spots or simply sit and enjoy a casual bite. It embodies the straightforward charm of island life.
It serves as a practical stop for provisions needed during your stay, whether for a day at the beach or a light dinner. The friendly service and authentic island vibe make it a worthwhile visit for anyone exploring Fishers Island.
Island Center, Fishers Island, NY · 0.5 miThe Flying Point Marina Grill
Situated near the marina, The Flying Point Marina Grill provides a vibrant waterfront dining experience with views of the harbor. It’s a popular spot for those looking to enjoy fresh seafood and classic American fare in a lively setting, often frequented by boaters and island visitors. The ambiance is typically energetic, especially during warmer months.
The menu is likely to feature a good selection of seafood, reflecting the bounty of the surrounding waters, alongside other popular dishes. It’s an excellent choice for lunch or dinner, offering a chance to soak in the maritime atmosphere of Fishers Island. The casual yet appealing environment makes it suitable for a variety of occasions.
Dining at The Flying Point Marina Grill offers a taste of the active marine community on Fishers Island. It’s a great place to observe the comings and goings of boats while enjoying a satisfying meal. This offers a different perspective on island life compared to the more tranquil golf course.
Fishers Island Marina, Fishers Island, NY · 1.2 miLocal & Elevated Picks
Seafood Shacks (Various)
Fishers Island is dotted with charming, often seasonal, seafood shacks that offer an authentic taste of the local catch. These unpretentious eateries focus on serving fresh lobster rolls, clam chowder, fried fish, and oysters, often with simple preparations that let the quality of the ingredients shine. Finding one of these spots is a delightful culinary adventure.
These establishments typically offer a very casual dining experience, sometimes with outdoor seating or limited indoor space. They are perfect for a relaxed meal after a day of golf or exploration, allowing you to savor the maritime flavors of the region. Look for local recommendations upon arrival.
Enjoying the fresh seafood from a local shack is a quintessential Fishers Island experience. It’s about simple pleasures and the direct connection to the ocean’s offerings. Each shack might have its own unique specialties, making exploration rewarding.
Various Locations, Fishers Island, NY · 0.5 - 3.0 miPrivate Catering / Rental Kitchens
For groups seeking a more personalized dining experience, many vacation rentals on Fishers Island come equipped with full kitchens. This allows for self-catering, where you can prepare meals using local ingredients purchased from the General Store or other island purveyors. This option provides maximum flexibility and can be cost-effective for larger parties.
Additionally, some local chefs or catering services may be available for private events or customized meal preparation at your rental. This offers the opportunity to enjoy expertly prepared meals in the comfort of your accommodation, tailored to your group’s preferences. Inquire about these services when booking accommodation.
This approach allows groups to curate their dining schedule, perhaps enjoying a casual lunch at a seafood shack one day and a fully catered dinner the next. It’s an excellent way to manage dining for a foursome or a family, ensuring everyone’s tastes and dietary needs are met.
Island-wide, Fishers Island, NY · VariableLocal Tips & Year-Round Info
- Ferry schedules are critical; always book passage and check for weather-related delays well in advance.
- Golf carts are less common on Fishers Island; consider bringing a bicycle or utilizing island taxis.
- Many island businesses are seasonal; confirm operating hours and availability, especially outside peak summer.
- Cell service can be spotty in certain areas of the island; be prepared with offline maps or alternative communication.
- Embrace the island's pace; relax, enjoy the natural beauty, and savor the unhurried atmosphere.
Weather & Seasons at HAY Harbor Golf Club
- Winter: Winter on Fishers Island brings chilly, often brisk, conditions with average temperatures ranging from the low 20s to high 30s Fahrenheit. Layers are essential, including thermal base layers, sweaters, and a heavy, windproof outer coat. Waterproof gloves and a warm hat are indispensable for comfort. Outdoor activities, including golf, are generally not feasible or advisable during this period.
- Spring & early summer: Spring ushers in milder weather, with temperatures gradually rising from the 40s into the 60s Fahrenheit. You’ll want to pack layers, including light jackets, sweaters, and perhaps a waterproof outer shell for unpredictable days. Early season golf might still require warmer layers, while late spring/early summer allows for lighter attire like polos and shorts.
- Mid-summer: Mid-summer brings the warmest temperatures, typically in the 70s and 80s Fahrenheit, with high humidity. Lightweight, breathable clothing is key: shorts, t-shirts, and moisture-wicking polo shirts are ideal for golf. Don't forget sun protection—a wide-brimmed hat, sunglasses, and high-SPF sunscreen are crucial for comfort and safety on the course.
- Fall season: Fall offers crisp air and fluctuating temperatures, generally ranging from the 50s to 70s Fahrenheit. Layers are again recommended, such as a long-sleeved shirt, a fleece or light sweater, and a windbreaker. Days can start cool and warm up considerably, so being able to shed layers is advantageous for a comfortable golfing experience.
- Rain & snow: Rain is possible throughout the year, though more frequent in spring and fall. A reliable waterproof jacket and perhaps waterproof pants are advisable for golfers. Snow is most likely during winter months, often accompanied by cold winds, making outdoor activities challenging. Always check the forecast before your travel and pack accordingly, prioritizing waterproof and windproof gear.
Venue Facts & Trip Essentials
Venue facts
- Primary team: N/A (Golf Club)
- Neighborhood: Eastern Fishers Island
- Nearest airport: Tweed-New Haven (Tweed-New Haven), CT
- Parking: Available at the golf club
- Walkable district: Limited, island exploration via bike/foot
Trip essentials
- Groceries & supplies: Fishers Island General Store
- Pharmacy: Limited; check General Store for basic items
- Urgent care: Basic first aid at club; nearest hospital requires ferry trip
- Downtime: Beaches, scenic drives, quiet village spots
- Pro tip: Book ferry and lodging far in advance, especially for summer visits.

