Hotels4Teams
Hotels near HAY Harbor Golf Club

Hotels near HAY Harbor Golf Club

Ettrick Ave, Fishers Island, NY

Quick dates:
HAY Harbor Golf Club
Check in – Check out
1 room

15 Hotels near HAY Harbor Golf Club

Multiple hotel sources, one search — rates you won't find on a single booking site.

Photo of Hampton Inn Groton Closest
From $181 / night 11.59 mi

Hampton Inn Groton

· 4.2 Very Good · 408 reviews

The promise is simple: your gear is safe and your comfort guaranteed.

  • Pick up bottled water and fresh fruit for the course
  • Access convenient on-site self-parking steps from your guest room door
  • Mingle with fellow golfers in comfortable casual gathering spaces
Free BreakfastGymWi-FiLaundryIndoor PoolEarly Check-In See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa
From $476 / night 11.69 mi

Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa

· 4.3 Very Good · 1,001 reviews

The professional choice for players who expect polished service every single time.

  • Grab premium coffee freshly brewed throughout your entire golf weekend
  • Charge your electric vehicle at convenient onsite EV stations
  • Utilize luggage rack to keep bags organized throughout weekend stay
RestaurantGymIndoor PoolPets OKEarly Check-InBar/LoungePaid Breakfast See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Rodeway Inn Groton - New London
From $40 / night 12.02 mi

Rodeway Inn Groton - New London

· 2.9 Fair · 378 reviews

Consistent value anchors golf trips when the real investment is time together.

  • Fuel your foursome with continental breakfast at select property locations
  • Access complimentary surface lot parking for entire group every day
  • Enjoy extra shower space from curved rods in en-suite baths
Free BreakfastEarly Check-InWi-FiLaundryPoolPets OK See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Motel 6 Groton CT—Casinos Nearby
From $71 / night 12.1 mi

Motel 6 Groton CT—Casinos Nearby

· 3.3 Average · 994 reviews

Predictable lodging lets foursomes focus spending where it matters most.

  • Maintain clean golf outfits throughout weekend tournaments with laundry access
  • Fuel up with complimentary freshly brewed coffee every morning
  • Store golf carts and transport vehicles in the generous surface lot
Wi-FiPoolLaundryPets OK See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Ramada by Wyndham Groton / Mystic
From $81 / night 12.63 mi

Ramada by Wyndham Groton / Mystic

· 3.2 Average · 829 reviews

A practical base for golfers seeking consistent quality at accessible rates.

  • Soak up sun on the poolside deck after morning rounds
  • Maintain sharp looks with in-room iron and full ironing board
  • Order full-service morning dining to match your exact tee time
Free BreakfastGymPets OKWi-FiEarly Check-InIndoor PoolLaundry See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Holiday Inn New London - Mystic Area by IHG
From $291 / night 12.69 mi

Holiday Inn New London - Mystic Area by IHG

· 4.2 Very Good · 845 reviews

Dependable hospitality designed around groups who gather to play and reconnect.

  • Recharge phones at built-in E-Bar outlets during afternoon breaks
  • Meet your foursome at the Lobby Bar for nightcap drinks
  • Block morning light completely with blackout roller shades installed
RestaurantGymEarly Check-InWi-FiLaundryPaid BreakfastBar/LoungePets OK See all ›
Check Availability

Booking 9+ rooms? Get group rates.

No upfront deposits Everyone pays separately Free coordinator room
Get Group Rates
Photo of Super 8 by Wyndham Groton
From $59 / night 12.75 mi

Super 8 by Wyndham Groton

· 3.1 Average · 1,121 reviews

Where reliable comfort costs less so foursomes spend more on what really matters.

  • Relax in comfortable communal spaces between morning and afternoon tee times
  • Customize comfort with a choice of firm or soft pillows
  • Choose from snack vending machines for quick energy between rounds
Free BreakfastBus ParkingEarly Check-InWi-FiIndoor PoolPets OKLaundry See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Hilton Garden Inn Mystic / Groton
From $199 / night 12.76 mi

Hilton Garden Inn Mystic / Groton

· 4.2 Very Good · 536 reviews

This hospitality leader balances modern ease with the warmth foursomes expect.

  • Sip cold beverages delivered directly to your poolside lounge area
  • Warm up by outdoor fire pits before early morning tee times
  • Step onto greens confidently after utilizing expert shoeshine service stations
RestaurantGymEarly Check-InWi-FiIndoor PoolBar/LoungeEV ChargingPets OK See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Hyatt Place Mystic Top rated
From $191 / night 13.23 mi

Hyatt Place Mystic

· 4.5 Excellent · 964 reviews

Designed for travelers who value closeness to the course over fuss.

  • Restore your golf attire with easy access to guest laundry
  • Recharge with fresh fruit and cage-free eggs after early practice
  • Schedule airport shuttle pickup after your final round concludes Sunday
Free BreakfastGymPets OKEarly Check-InWi-FiBar/LoungeKitchenIndoor Pool See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Howard Johnson by Wyndham Mystic
From $112 / night 13.44 mi

Howard Johnson by Wyndham Mystic

· 3.4 Average · 1,570 reviews

Value without compromise for players who prioritize the course over extras.

  • Rely on 24-hour front desk assistance for course recommendations
  • Recharge on Wyndham standard plush bedding between tournament rounds tomorrow
  • Fill coolers with ice before heading to the course
Free BreakfastWi-FiLaundryPets OKIndoor PoolEarly Check-In See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Hilton Mystic
From $726 / night 13.46 mi

Hilton Mystic

· 4.2 Very Good

The full-service standard foursomes trust for post-round drinks and group dinners.

  • Start strong with freshly baked artisanal pastries and breakfast sandwiches
  • Start your golf getaway with complimentary shuttle service from airport
  • Store watches and phones safely in convenient in-room digital safes
RestaurantGymIndoor PoolEarly Check-InPets OKShuttleLaundryBar/Lounge See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Hampton Inn & Suites Mystic
From $216 / night 13.93 mi

Hampton Inn & Suites Mystic

· 4.4 Very Good · 967 reviews

This stay delivers comfort you count on plus service you actually remember.

  • Rinse off quickly with the high-pressure Waterpik showerhead
  • Enjoy hot chocolate while reviewing scorecards with your foursome
  • Grab complimentary pool towels and relax on lounge seating
Free BreakfastGymEarly Check-InLaundryIndoor PoolWi-Fi See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Best Western Mystic Hotel Best value
From $131 / night 14.01 mi

Best Western Mystic Hotel

· 4.3 Very Good · 80 reviews

Built for golfers who value predictable comfort between long course days.

  • Watch live golf coverage on the lobby's large-screen television
  • Customize comfort with both plush and firm pillow selections
  • Fuel late practice sessions with snacks from convenient vending
Free BreakfastGymPets OKEarly Check-InLaundryIndoor PoolWi-Fi See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Residence Inn by Marriott Mystic Groton
From $289 / night 14.08 mi

Residence Inn by Marriott Mystic Groton

· 4.0 Very Good · 301 reviews

Extended-stay flexibility meets the rhythm golfers actually keep on multi-round trips.

  • Recover from challenging courses in the property's soothing hot tub
  • Connect with other golfers at the inviting fire pit area
  • Tackle post-round laundry with on-site coin or card-operated machines
Free BreakfastGymEV ChargingShuttleWi-FiLaundryKitchenIndoor Pool See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Spark by Hilton Mystic Groton
From $113 / night 14.14 mi

Spark by Hilton Mystic Groton

· 4.2 Very Good · 1,200 reviews

This established brand serves golfers who prioritize swift starts and dependable full-service support.

  • Savor expertly crafted cocktails after your final round each evening
  • Choose allergen-free pillow options for your best sleep ever
  • Recharge with late-night room service after long tournament days
RestaurantGymEarly Check-InLaundryIndoor PoolBar/LoungeWi-FiEV Charging See all ›
Check Availability
Hotel offerings and amenities can change. Check the hotel page for up-to-date details.
Local Area Guide

HAY Harbor Golf Club Travel Guide

We built this guide so your team doesn't have to figure it all out from a Google search. Neighborhoods, restaurants, game day logistics, local tips — it's all here.

HAY Harbor Golf Club offers a premier golfing experience on the picturesque Fishers Island. This guide is designed for visiting golfers, providing essential information to help you plan your trip and maximize your enjoyment of the course and the surrounding area. Navigate your way from arrival to the final putt with insights on local amenities, dining, and practical tips for a seamless golf getaway. Get ready to experience world-class golf with stunning coastal views. We'll cover everything from the best routes to the club, where to find comfortable lodging, and how to make the most of your time on and off the greens. Prepare for a memorable outing tailored to the unique charm of Fishers Island.

Section 01

Neighborhood Overview

Nestled on the eastern tip of Fishers Island, HAY Harbor Golf Club is situated in a unique maritime environment. Access to Fishers Island is primarily by ferry from New London, Connecticut, or Orient Point, New York. The island itself is characterized by rolling hills, coastal bluffs, and a serene, relatively undeveloped landscape.

Approaching the club involves arriving on the island via ferry and then navigating local roads. Given the island's size and limited vehicle traffic, cycling or walking are popular modes of transport once you've reached your accommodation. Parking at the club is generally ample and convenient for those arriving by car, with dedicated spaces for members and guests.

The nearest major airport is Tweed New Haven Regional Airport (Tweed-New Haven) in Connecticut, approximately a 45-minute drive from the New London ferry terminal, plus the ferry journey. Alternatively, Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP) is a drive to the Orient Point ferry. It's crucial to plan your ferry schedule carefully, as sailings can be impacted by weather and are less frequent than mainland transport. Allow ample time for ferry travel and connections to ensure a relaxed arrival before your tee time.

Section 02

Where to Stay

Lodging options on Fishers Island are somewhat limited and often booked well in advance, especially during peak golf season. Many visitors opt for vacation rentals or charming inns scattered across the island. These accommodations provide a more immersive experience of island life and are generally a short drive or bike ride from HAY Harbor Golf Club.

Given the island's scale, most accommodations are within a few miles of the golf club, making it convenient to access. It’s highly recommended to secure your lodging as early as possible, particularly if you’re visiting for a specific tournament or during summer months. Consider locations that offer easy access to both the golf club and ferry terminals.

Booking strategies should focus on early reservations and checking availability for different types of stays, from single rooms to entire homes for a foursome. Some hotels and rental agencies on the mainland near ferry terminals also serve as viable options if island lodging is unavailable, though this adds significant travel time each day. Utilize map views to understand proximity to ferry docks and the golf course itself.

Section 03

Quick-Plan Overview

Arrival & Parking

Arrive via ferry from New London, CT or Orient Point, NY, followed by a short drive or bike ride.

Tip

Allow extra time for ferry boarding and travel; check schedules in advance.

Downtime

Enjoy the island's natural beauty with a walk or bike ride between rounds.

Food & Dining

Explore local seafood shacks or enjoy a cozy meal at a village restaurant.

Food & Dining

Recharge at your lodging or a quiet island cafe after a day on the course.

  • Arrive via ferry from New London, CT or Orient Point, NY, followed by a short drive or bike ride.
  • Allow extra time for ferry boarding and travel; check schedules in advance.
  • Enjoy the island's natural beauty with a walk or bike ride between rounds.
  • Explore local seafood shacks or enjoy a cozy meal at a village restaurant.
  • Recharge at your lodging or a quiet island cafe after a day on the course.
Section 04

Round Day Flow

Check-In & Warm-Up

Plan to arrive at HAY Harbor Golf Club at least 45-60 minutes before your scheduled tee time. This allows ample time to disembark your ferry, travel to the club, check in at the pro shop, and prepare for your round. Take advantage of the club's practice facilities to get a feel for the greens and fairways.

Mid-Day Regroup

Following your initial nine holes, take a moment to regroup at the clubhouse or designated halfway house if available. This break is an opportunity to refresh, discuss the front nine, and make any necessary adjustments to your game plan for the back nine. Many golfers find this pause essential for sustained performance.

Wrap-Up & Departure

After completing your round at HAY Harbor Golf Club, take time to properly conclude your golfing experience. Return your clubs, settle any outstanding accounts at the pro shop, and enjoy a final beverage or meal at the clubhouse. This is a great time to reflect on the day’s play and enjoy the club’s ambiance.

Check-In & Warm-Up

Plan to arrive at HAY Harbor Golf Club at least 45-60 minutes before your scheduled tee time. This allows ample time to disembark your ferry, travel to the club, check in at the pro shop, and prepare for your round. Take advantage of the club's practice facilities to get a feel for the greens and fairways.

Familiarize yourself with the course layout and any specific local rules before heading to the first tee. The pro shop staff can provide valuable insights into course conditions and any play considerations for the day. This buffer time ensures a relaxed start, free from the rush of last-minute preparations.

Utilize the driving range and putting green to warm up your swing and get a sense of the club's turf. This preparatory phase is crucial for setting a positive tone for your game. Enjoy the serene island atmosphere as you transition from travel mode to golf mode.

Consider a light snack or beverage from the clubhouse to fuel your round. Staying hydrated and energized is key to maintaining focus throughout your game. The aim is to be fully ready and composed when it's time to play your first shot.

Confirm your group's readiness and review your strategy one last time. The pro shop is the central hub for all pre-game logistics and inquiries.

Mid-Day Regroup

Following your initial nine holes, take a moment to regroup at the clubhouse or designated halfway house if available. This break is an opportunity to refresh, discuss the front nine, and make any necessary adjustments to your game plan for the back nine. Many golfers find this pause essential for sustained performance.

Enjoy a quick lunch or a refreshing beverage to refuel. The club's dining facilities offer a chance to relax and socialize with your playing partners. It’s also a good time to check on any messages or briefly connect with those not on the course.

Observe the changing wind patterns or sun position as they might affect play in the afternoon. These environmental shifts can be significant on a coastal course like HAY Harbor. Understanding these nuances can provide a strategic advantage.

This mid-game pause is more than just a break; it’s a strategic reset. It allows players to re-center their focus and approach the latter half of the round with renewed energy and a clear mind. Embrace the island pace during this interval.

Take this time to mentally prepare for the challenges ahead, ensuring you’re ready to tackle the remaining holes with confidence.

Wrap-Up & Departure

After completing your round at HAY Harbor Golf Club, take time to properly conclude your golfing experience. Return your clubs, settle any outstanding accounts at the pro shop, and enjoy a final beverage or meal at the clubhouse. This is a great time to reflect on the day’s play and enjoy the club’s ambiance.

If you’re departing the island the same day, factor in sufficient time to return to your ferry terminal. Allow for potential delays, especially during peak travel times or if weather conditions are a factor. A relaxed departure contributes to the overall positive experience.

Consider purchasing any desired souvenirs or club merchandise as a memento of your visit. The pro shop often has unique items reflecting the club's identity and the island’s charm. These make for great keepsakes or gifts for fellow golf enthusiasts.

For those staying longer, plan your next activity or relaxation period. Whether it’s exploring more of Fishers Island or simply unwinding, ensure a smooth transition from the golf course. The island offers numerous quiet spots for post-golf leisure.

Ensure all personal belongings are gathered before leaving the club premises. A thorough check prevents any forgotten items and ensures a clean exit.

Section 05

Things to Do

Walkable

Fishers Island Ferry Terminal

On site

The heart of island connectivity, the ferry terminal serves as the primary gateway for visitors arriving by sea. It's a bustling point where islanders and tourists alike transition between the mainland and the tranquil shores of Fishers Island. Close proximity to the golf club means a seamless arrival and departure experience for many. Beyond its practical function, the terminal area offers a glimpse into island life. You'll find small shops and places to grab a quick bite, perfect for a pre- or post-round snack. The scenic views of the water from the docks provide a pleasant introduction to the island's natural beauty. It's a convenient spot to arrange transportation or simply enjoy the coastal atmosphere before heading to HAY Harbor. The rhythm of the ferries dictates a portion of the island's daily cadence, making the terminal a central hub of activity.

Fishers Island General Store

0.5 mi

A cornerstone of the island community, the Fishers Island General Store is more than just a place to buy provisions; it’s a social hub. Visitors can find a variety of essentials, from snacks and beverages to local souvenirs, making it a convenient stop before or after a round of golf. It offers a taste of local commerce and island living. The store often stocks items catering to both residents and seasonal visitors, including beach gear, local crafts, and everyday necessities. Grabbing a quick lunch or a picnic item here is a popular choice for those looking to enjoy the island’s scenic spots. Its central location makes it easily accessible. Engaging with the friendly staff provides a personal touch and insight into the island’s character. It’s a reliable spot to pick up anything you might have forgotten for your day at HAY Harbor or to find a unique memento of your trip.

5–15 Minutes Away

Fishers Island Lighthouse

3.0 mi

Standing sentinel on the island's easternmost point, the Fishers Island Lighthouse offers a picturesque landmark and a glimpse into maritime history. While access to the lighthouse itself might be restricted, the surrounding area provides stunning panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean and Long Island Sound. It's a beautiful spot for a contemplative walk or to appreciate the island's rugged coastline. The drive to the lighthouse is part of the experience, winding through scenic island roads that showcase the unique topography and natural beauty. This area is often less populated, offering a sense of peaceful seclusion. Keep an eye out for local wildlife and the dramatic coastal flora. Visiting this iconic structure provides a different perspective on the island's charm, away from the fairways of HAY Harbor. It's an ideal location for photography enthusiasts and those seeking a moment of quiet reflection amidst dramatic natural scenery. The sea breeze and expansive horizons are truly invigorating.

Isabella Beach

2.5 mi

Isabella Beach is one of Fishers Island's gems, offering a serene stretch of shoreline perfect for relaxation and enjoying coastal vistas. Whether you’re looking for a place to unwind after a challenging round at HAY Harbor or simply want to experience the island's natural beauty, this beach provides a tranquil escape. The gentle waves and sandy shores are inviting. The beach is ideal for a leisurely stroll, picnicking, or simply soaking up the sun. Its location on the south shore means it often catches the sun throughout the day, making it a pleasant spot regardless of the time. Pack some refreshments from the General Store for a perfect beachside break. Accessing Isabella Beach is part of the adventure, often involving navigating charming island roads. The relatively undeveloped nature of Fishers Island means that beaches like Isabella retain a natural, uncrowded feel, offering a genuine retreat from the everyday. It’s a perfect counterpoint to the focused intensity of golf.

Walkable

  • Fishers Island Ferry Terminal — The heart of island connectivity, the ferry terminal serves as the primary gateway for visitors arriving by sea. It's a bustling point where islanders and tourists alike transition between the mainland and the tranquil shores of Fishers Island. Close proximity to the golf club means a seamless arrival and departure experience for many. Beyond its practical function, the terminal area offers a glimpse into island life. You'll find small shops and places to grab a quick bite, perfect for a pre- or post-round snack. The scenic views of the water from the docks provide a pleasant introduction to the island's natural beauty. It's a convenient spot to arrange transportation or simply enjoy the coastal atmosphere before heading to HAY Harbor. The rhythm of the ferries dictates a portion of the island's daily cadence, making the terminal a central hub of activity. On site
  • Fishers Island General Store — A cornerstone of the island community, the Fishers Island General Store is more than just a place to buy provisions; it’s a social hub. Visitors can find a variety of essentials, from snacks and beverages to local souvenirs, making it a convenient stop before or after a round of golf. It offers a taste of local commerce and island living. The store often stocks items catering to both residents and seasonal visitors, including beach gear, local crafts, and everyday necessities. Grabbing a quick lunch or a picnic item here is a popular choice for those looking to enjoy the island’s scenic spots. Its central location makes it easily accessible. Engaging with the friendly staff provides a personal touch and insight into the island’s character. It’s a reliable spot to pick up anything you might have forgotten for your day at HAY Harbor or to find a unique memento of your trip. 0.5 mi

5–15 Minutes Away

  • Fishers Island Lighthouse — Standing sentinel on the island's easternmost point, the Fishers Island Lighthouse offers a picturesque landmark and a glimpse into maritime history. While access to the lighthouse itself might be restricted, the surrounding area provides stunning panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean and Long Island Sound. It's a beautiful spot for a contemplative walk or to appreciate the island's rugged coastline. The drive to the lighthouse is part of the experience, winding through scenic island roads that showcase the unique topography and natural beauty. This area is often less populated, offering a sense of peaceful seclusion. Keep an eye out for local wildlife and the dramatic coastal flora. Visiting this iconic structure provides a different perspective on the island's charm, away from the fairways of HAY Harbor. It's an ideal location for photography enthusiasts and those seeking a moment of quiet reflection amidst dramatic natural scenery. The sea breeze and expansive horizons are truly invigorating. 3.0 mi
  • Isabella Beach — Isabella Beach is one of Fishers Island's gems, offering a serene stretch of shoreline perfect for relaxation and enjoying coastal vistas. Whether you’re looking for a place to unwind after a challenging round at HAY Harbor or simply want to experience the island's natural beauty, this beach provides a tranquil escape. The gentle waves and sandy shores are inviting. The beach is ideal for a leisurely stroll, picnicking, or simply soaking up the sun. Its location on the south shore means it often catches the sun throughout the day, making it a pleasant spot regardless of the time. Pack some refreshments from the General Store for a perfect beachside break. Accessing Isabella Beach is part of the adventure, often involving navigating charming island roads. The relatively undeveloped nature of Fishers Island means that beaches like Isabella retain a natural, uncrowded feel, offering a genuine retreat from the everyday. It’s a perfect counterpoint to the focused intensity of golf. 2.5 mi
Section 06

Food & Drink

Inside & Adjacent

HAY Harbor Golf Club Dining Room

On site

The dining room at HAY Harbor Golf Club offers a convenient and refined option for golfers looking to enjoy a meal without leaving the club premises. With potential views overlooking the course, it provides a pleasant atmosphere for breakfast, lunch, or post-round refreshments. The menu typically features a selection of classic dishes suitable for a golf club setting. It's the perfect spot for a quick bite between nines or a more leisurely meal after completing your round. The focus here is on providing a comfortable dining experience that complements your day of golf. Enjoying a meal here means maximizing your time on the island and minimizing travel. The ambiance is generally relaxed yet sophisticated, catering to the club's clientele. Expect attentive service and a menu that aims to satisfy the appetites of golfers. It’s an integral part of the overall HAY Harbor experience, offering both sustenance and a place to socialize.

The Pequot Inn Restaurant

0.7 mi

The Pequot Inn Restaurant is a well-regarded establishment on Fishers Island, known for offering a taste of local flavor in a welcoming setting. It serves as a popular gathering spot for both island residents and visitors, providing a relaxed environment to enjoy well-prepared meals. Its proximity to the golf club makes it an accessible choice for post-game dining or a meal before heading to the ferry. The menu often highlights fresh, seasonal ingredients, with a particular emphasis on seafood, a staple in this coastal community. Diners can expect a menu that balances familiar favorites with dishes that reflect the island’s culinary heritage. It’s a place where you can savor the essence of Fishers Island cuisine. Whether you're seeking a casual lunch or a more formal dinner, The Pequot Inn Restaurant aims to provide a satisfying experience. The island atmosphere pervades the dining space, making it an ideal location to unwind and reflect on your day’s adventures, including your time on the links.

Nearby Gathering Spots

Fishers Island General Store Cafe

0.5 mi

While primarily a general store, the cafe section offers a casual and convenient spot for light meals, snacks, and beverages. It’s a quintessential island experience, allowing visitors to grab a coffee, a sandwich, or some local baked goods in a relaxed, unpretentious atmosphere. This is a perfect place for a quick refuel after a game or while exploring the island. The cafe’s informal setting makes it ideal for families or groups looking for an easygoing meal. You can pick up picnic supplies here to enjoy at one of the island’s scenic spots or simply sit and enjoy a casual bite. It embodies the straightforward charm of island life. It serves as a practical stop for provisions needed during your stay, whether for a day at the beach or a light dinner. The friendly service and authentic island vibe make it a worthwhile visit for anyone exploring Fishers Island.

The Flying Point Marina Grill

1.2 mi

Situated near the marina, The Flying Point Marina Grill provides a vibrant waterfront dining experience with views of the harbor. It’s a popular spot for those looking to enjoy fresh seafood and classic American fare in a lively setting, often frequented by boaters and island visitors. The ambiance is typically energetic, especially during warmer months. The menu is likely to feature a good selection of seafood, reflecting the bounty of the surrounding waters, alongside other popular dishes. It’s an excellent choice for lunch or dinner, offering a chance to soak in the maritime atmosphere of Fishers Island. The casual yet appealing environment makes it suitable for a variety of occasions. Dining at The Flying Point Marina Grill offers a taste of the active marine community on Fishers Island. It’s a great place to observe the comings and goings of boats while enjoying a satisfying meal. This offers a different perspective on island life compared to the more tranquil golf course.

Local & Elevated Picks

Seafood Shacks (Various)

0.5 - 3.0 mi

Fishers Island is dotted with charming, often seasonal, seafood shacks that offer an authentic taste of the local catch. These unpretentious eateries focus on serving fresh lobster rolls, clam chowder, fried fish, and oysters, often with simple preparations that let the quality of the ingredients shine. Finding one of these spots is a delightful culinary adventure. These establishments typically offer a very casual dining experience, sometimes with outdoor seating or limited indoor space. They are perfect for a relaxed meal after a day of golf or exploration, allowing you to savor the maritime flavors of the region. Look for local recommendations upon arrival. Enjoying the fresh seafood from a local shack is a quintessential Fishers Island experience. It’s about simple pleasures and the direct connection to the ocean’s offerings. Each shack might have its own unique specialties, making exploration rewarding.

Private Catering / Rental Kitchens

Variable

For groups seeking a more personalized dining experience, many vacation rentals on Fishers Island come equipped with full kitchens. This allows for self-catering, where you can prepare meals using local ingredients purchased from the General Store or other island purveyors. This option provides maximum flexibility and can be cost-effective for larger parties. Additionally, some local chefs or catering services may be available for private events or customized meal preparation at your rental. This offers the opportunity to enjoy expertly prepared meals in the comfort of your accommodation, tailored to your group’s preferences. Inquire about these services when booking accommodation. This approach allows groups to curate their dining schedule, perhaps enjoying a casual lunch at a seafood shack one day and a fully catered dinner the next. It’s an excellent way to manage dining for a foursome or a family, ensuring everyone’s tastes and dietary needs are met.

Inside & Adjacent

  • HAY Harbor Golf Club Dining Room — The dining room at HAY Harbor Golf Club offers a convenient and refined option for golfers looking to enjoy a meal without leaving the club premises. With potential views overlooking the course, it provides a pleasant atmosphere for breakfast, lunch, or post-round refreshments. The menu typically features a selection of classic dishes suitable for a golf club setting. It's the perfect spot for a quick bite between nines or a more leisurely meal after completing your round. The focus here is on providing a comfortable dining experience that complements your day of golf. Enjoying a meal here means maximizing your time on the island and minimizing travel. The ambiance is generally relaxed yet sophisticated, catering to the club's clientele. Expect attentive service and a menu that aims to satisfy the appetites of golfers. It’s an integral part of the overall HAY Harbor experience, offering both sustenance and a place to socialize. On site
  • The Pequot Inn Restaurant — The Pequot Inn Restaurant is a well-regarded establishment on Fishers Island, known for offering a taste of local flavor in a welcoming setting. It serves as a popular gathering spot for both island residents and visitors, providing a relaxed environment to enjoy well-prepared meals. Its proximity to the golf club makes it an accessible choice for post-game dining or a meal before heading to the ferry. The menu often highlights fresh, seasonal ingredients, with a particular emphasis on seafood, a staple in this coastal community. Diners can expect a menu that balances familiar favorites with dishes that reflect the island’s culinary heritage. It’s a place where you can savor the essence of Fishers Island cuisine. Whether you're seeking a casual lunch or a more formal dinner, The Pequot Inn Restaurant aims to provide a satisfying experience. The island atmosphere pervades the dining space, making it an ideal location to unwind and reflect on your day’s adventures, including your time on the links. 0.7 mi

Nearby Gathering Spots

  • Fishers Island General Store Cafe — While primarily a general store, the cafe section offers a casual and convenient spot for light meals, snacks, and beverages. It’s a quintessential island experience, allowing visitors to grab a coffee, a sandwich, or some local baked goods in a relaxed, unpretentious atmosphere. This is a perfect place for a quick refuel after a game or while exploring the island. The cafe’s informal setting makes it ideal for families or groups looking for an easygoing meal. You can pick up picnic supplies here to enjoy at one of the island’s scenic spots or simply sit and enjoy a casual bite. It embodies the straightforward charm of island life. It serves as a practical stop for provisions needed during your stay, whether for a day at the beach or a light dinner. The friendly service and authentic island vibe make it a worthwhile visit for anyone exploring Fishers Island. 0.5 mi
  • The Flying Point Marina Grill — Situated near the marina, The Flying Point Marina Grill provides a vibrant waterfront dining experience with views of the harbor. It’s a popular spot for those looking to enjoy fresh seafood and classic American fare in a lively setting, often frequented by boaters and island visitors. The ambiance is typically energetic, especially during warmer months. The menu is likely to feature a good selection of seafood, reflecting the bounty of the surrounding waters, alongside other popular dishes. It’s an excellent choice for lunch or dinner, offering a chance to soak in the maritime atmosphere of Fishers Island. The casual yet appealing environment makes it suitable for a variety of occasions. Dining at The Flying Point Marina Grill offers a taste of the active marine community on Fishers Island. It’s a great place to observe the comings and goings of boats while enjoying a satisfying meal. This offers a different perspective on island life compared to the more tranquil golf course. 1.2 mi

Local & Elevated Picks

  • Seafood Shacks (Various) — Fishers Island is dotted with charming, often seasonal, seafood shacks that offer an authentic taste of the local catch. These unpretentious eateries focus on serving fresh lobster rolls, clam chowder, fried fish, and oysters, often with simple preparations that let the quality of the ingredients shine. Finding one of these spots is a delightful culinary adventure. These establishments typically offer a very casual dining experience, sometimes with outdoor seating or limited indoor space. They are perfect for a relaxed meal after a day of golf or exploration, allowing you to savor the maritime flavors of the region. Look for local recommendations upon arrival. Enjoying the fresh seafood from a local shack is a quintessential Fishers Island experience. It’s about simple pleasures and the direct connection to the ocean’s offerings. Each shack might have its own unique specialties, making exploration rewarding. 0.5 - 3.0 mi
  • Private Catering / Rental Kitchens — For groups seeking a more personalized dining experience, many vacation rentals on Fishers Island come equipped with full kitchens. This allows for self-catering, where you can prepare meals using local ingredients purchased from the General Store or other island purveyors. This option provides maximum flexibility and can be cost-effective for larger parties. Additionally, some local chefs or catering services may be available for private events or customized meal preparation at your rental. This offers the opportunity to enjoy expertly prepared meals in the comfort of your accommodation, tailored to your group’s preferences. Inquire about these services when booking accommodation. This approach allows groups to curate their dining schedule, perhaps enjoying a casual lunch at a seafood shack one day and a fully catered dinner the next. It’s an excellent way to manage dining for a foursome or a family, ensuring everyone’s tastes and dietary needs are met. Variable
Section 07

Local Tips

Ferry schedules are critical: always book passage and check for weather-related delays well in advance.

Golf carts are less common on Fishers Island: consider bringing a bicycle or utilizing island taxis.

Many island businesses are seasonal: confirm operating hours and availability, especially outside peak summer.

Cell service can be spotty in certain areas of the island: be prepared with offline maps or alternative communication.

Embrace the island's pace: relax, enjoy the natural beauty, and savor the unhurried atmosphere.

Seasonal note: Fishers Island transforms with the seasons, each offering a distinct appeal for visitors to HAY Harbor Golf Club. Spring brings a gentle awakening with blooming flora and milder temperatures, ideal for early-season golf before the summer crowds arrive. Summer is the peak season, characterized by warm, sunny days perfect for golf and beach activities, though it also means higher demand for accommodations and ferry services. Fall offers crisp air, beautiful foliage, and a return to a more tranquil island atmosphere, making it a wonderful time for golf with fewer visitors. Winter is quiet and serene, with limited services available, primarily suited for hardy locals or those seeking absolute solitude. Travel ease varies significantly, with summer and fall offering the most consistent ferry operations, while winter may see more disruptions due to weather.

  • Ferry schedules are critical always book passage and check for weather-related delays well in advance.
  • Golf carts are less common on Fishers Island consider bringing a bicycle or utilizing island taxis.
  • Many island businesses are seasonal confirm operating hours and availability, especially outside peak summer.
  • Cell service can be spotty in certain areas of the island be prepared with offline maps or alternative communication.
  • Embrace the island's pace relax, enjoy the natural beauty, and savor the unhurried atmosphere.
  • Seasonal note: Fishers Island transforms with the seasons, each offering a distinct appeal for visitors to HAY Harbor Golf Club. Spring brings a gentle awakening with blooming flora and milder temperatures, ideal for early-season golf before the summer crowds arrive. Summer is the peak season, characterized by warm, sunny days perfect for golf and beach activities, though it also means higher demand for accommodations and ferry services. Fall offers crisp air, beautiful foliage, and a return to a more tranquil island atmosphere, making it a wonderful time for golf with fewer visitors. Winter is quiet and serene, with limited services available, primarily suited for hardy locals or those seeking absolute solitude. Travel ease varies significantly, with summer and fall offering the most consistent ferry operations, while winter may see more disruptions due to weather.
Section 08

Weather & Seasons

❄️

Winter

Winter on Fishers Island brings chilly, often brisk, conditions with average temperatures ranging from the low 20s to high 30s Fahrenheit. Layers are essential, including thermal base layers, sweaters, and a heavy, windproof outer coat. Waterproof gloves and a warm hat are indispensable for comfort. Outdoor activities, including golf, are generally not feasible or advisable during this period.

🌱

Spring & early summer

Spring ushers in milder weather, with temperatures gradually rising from the 40s into the 60s Fahrenheit. You’ll want to pack layers, including light jackets, sweaters, and perhaps a waterproof outer shell for unpredictable days. Early season golf might still require warmer layers, while late spring/early summer allows for lighter attire like polos and shorts.

☀️

Mid-summer

Mid-summer brings the warmest temperatures, typically in the 70s and 80s Fahrenheit, with high humidity. Lightweight, breathable clothing is key: shorts, t-shirts, and moisture-wicking polo shirts are ideal for golf. Don't forget sun protection—a wide-brimmed hat, sunglasses, and high-SPF sunscreen are crucial for comfort and safety on the course.

🍂

Fall season

Fall offers crisp air and fluctuating temperatures, generally ranging from the 50s to 70s Fahrenheit. Layers are again recommended, such as a long-sleeved shirt, a fleece or light sweater, and a windbreaker. Days can start cool and warm up considerably, so being able to shed layers is advantageous for a comfortable golfing experience.

📅

Rain & snow

Rain is possible throughout the year, though more frequent in spring and fall. A reliable waterproof jacket and perhaps waterproof pants are advisable for golfers. Snow is most likely during winter months, often accompanied by cold winds, making outdoor activities challenging. Always check the forecast before your travel and pack accordingly, prioritizing waterproof and windproof gear.

Winter

Winter on Fishers Island brings chilly, often brisk, conditions with average temperatures ranging from the low 20s to high 30s Fahrenheit. Layers are essential, including thermal base layers, sweaters, and a heavy, windproof outer coat. Waterproof gloves and a warm hat are indispensable for comfort. Outdoor activities, including golf, are generally not feasible or advisable during this period.

Spring & early summer

Spring ushers in milder weather, with temperatures gradually rising from the 40s into the 60s Fahrenheit. You’ll want to pack layers, including light jackets, sweaters, and perhaps a waterproof outer shell for unpredictable days. Early season golf might still require warmer layers, while late spring/early summer allows for lighter attire like polos and shorts.

Mid-summer

Mid-summer brings the warmest temperatures, typically in the 70s and 80s Fahrenheit, with high humidity. Lightweight, breathable clothing is key: shorts, t-shirts, and moisture-wicking polo shirts are ideal for golf. Don't forget sun protection—a wide-brimmed hat, sunglasses, and high-SPF sunscreen are crucial for comfort and safety on the course.

Fall season

Fall offers crisp air and fluctuating temperatures, generally ranging from the 50s to 70s Fahrenheit. Layers are again recommended, such as a long-sleeved shirt, a fleece or light sweater, and a windbreaker. Days can start cool and warm up considerably, so being able to shed layers is advantageous for a comfortable golfing experience.

Rain & snow

Rain is possible throughout the year, though more frequent in spring and fall. A reliable waterproof jacket and perhaps waterproof pants are advisable for golfers. Snow is most likely during winter months, often accompanied by cold winds, making outdoor activities challenging. Always check the forecast before your travel and pack accordingly, prioritizing waterproof and windproof gear.

Section 09

Venue Facts

Primary team

N/A (Golf Club)

Neighborhood

Eastern Fishers Island

Nearest airport

Tweed-New Haven (Tweed-New Haven), CT

Parking

Available at the golf club

Walkable district

Limited, island exploration via bike/foot

Groceries & supplies

Fishers Island General Store

Pharmacy

Limited; check General Store for basic items

Urgent care

Basic first aid at club; nearest hospital requires ferry trip

Downtime

Beaches, scenic drives, quiet village spots

Pro tip

Book ferry and lodging far in advance, especially for summer visits.

Primary teamN/A (Golf Club)
NeighborhoodEastern Fishers Island
Nearest airportTweed-New Haven (Tweed-New Haven), CT
ParkingAvailable at the golf club
Walkable districtLimited, island exploration via bike/foot
Groceries & suppliesFishers Island General Store
PharmacyLimited; check General Store for basic items
Urgent careBasic first aid at club; nearest hospital requires ferry trip
DowntimeBeaches, scenic drives, quiet village spots
Pro tipBook ferry and lodging far in advance, especially for summer visits.
Need to Know

Frequently Asked Questions

Real questions travelers ask before booking near HAY Harbor Golf Club — answered with the specifics you actually need.

Questions Travelers Ask What people want to know before booking near HAY Harbor Golf Club

What are the closest hotels to HAY Harbor Golf Club?

The closest hotel to HAY Harbor Golf Club is Hampton Inn Groton (11.59 mi, from $181/night) — a 23-minute drive. Other nearby options include Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa (11.69 mi, from $476/night) and Rodeway Inn Groton - New London (12.02 mi, from $40/night). Hampton Inn Groton offers free breakfast, a pool, and a fitness center. Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa offers free breakfast, a pool, and a fitness center. Rodeway Inn Groton - New London offers free breakfast and a pool.

Are there upscale or luxury hotels near HAY Harbor Golf Club?

Several upscale hotels are available near HAY Harbor Golf Club. Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa (11.69 mi, from $476/night), Hilton Garden Inn Mystic / Groton (12.76 mi, from $199/night), and Hilton Mystic (13.46 mi, from $726/night) all offer on-site dining, room service, and a pool.

Which hotels near HAY Harbor Golf Club are great for a weekend getaway?

Several hotels near HAY Harbor Golf Club are ideal for a weekend getaway. Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa (11.69 mi, from $476/night), Hilton Garden Inn Mystic / Groton (12.76 mi, from $199/night), and Hilton Mystic (13.46 mi, from $726/night) all offer a pool and on-site dining.

Which hotels near HAY Harbor Golf Club are good for families?

Several hotels near HAY Harbor Golf Club are well-suited for families. Hampton Inn Groton (11.59 mi, from $181/night), Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa (11.69 mi, from $476/night), and Ramada by Wyndham Groton / Mystic (12.63 mi, from $81/night) all offer suites, connecting rooms, a pool, complimentary breakfast, and on-site laundry.

Which hotels near HAY Harbor Golf Club are good for team or group travel?

Several hotels near HAY Harbor Golf Club accommodate team and group travel. Hampton Inn Groton (11.59 mi, from $181/night), Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa (11.69 mi, from $476/night), and Ramada by Wyndham Groton / Mystic (12.63 mi, from $81/night) all offer meeting space, complimentary breakfast, and on-site laundry.

Hotel Amenities & Features Pools, breakfast, pet policies, and more

Which hotels near HAY Harbor Golf Club offer free breakfast?

Hampton Inn Groton (11.59 mi, from $181/night), Rodeway Inn Groton - New London (12.02 mi, from $40/night), and Ramada by Wyndham Groton / Mystic (12.63 mi, from $81/night) include complimentary breakfast.

Which hotels near HAY Harbor Golf Club offer free parking?

Hampton Inn Groton (11.59 mi, from $181/night), Rodeway Inn Groton - New London (12.02 mi, from $40/night), and Motel 6 Groton CT—Casinos Nearby (12.1 mi, from $71/night) offer complimentary parking.

Which hotels near HAY Harbor Golf Club have a fitness center?

Hampton Inn Groton (11.59 mi, from $181/night), Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa (11.69 mi, from $476/night), and Ramada by Wyndham Groton / Mystic (12.63 mi, from $81/night) have an on-site fitness center.

Which hotels near HAY Harbor Golf Club have an outdoor pool?

Rodeway Inn Groton - New London (12.02 mi, from $40/night) and Motel 6 Groton CT—Casinos Nearby (12.1 mi, from $71/night) have an outdoor pool.

Do any hotels near HAY Harbor Golf Club offer a shuttle?

Yes — Hilton Garden Inn Mystic / Groton (12.76 mi, from $199/night), Hyatt Place Mystic (13.23 mi, from $191/night), and Hilton Mystic (13.46 mi, from $726/night) offer shuttle service.

Ready to book near HAY Harbor Golf Club?

15 hotels to choose from. Lowest rate guarantee, flexible cancellation on most rooms, and a support team that gets sports travel.