Hotels4Teams
Hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club

Hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club

12 Dinah Rock Rd, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Quick dates:
Gardiner's Bay Country Club
Check in – Check out
1 room

12 Hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club

Multiple hotel sources, one search — rates you won't find on a single booking site.

Photo of The Harbor Front Inn Closest
From $224 / night 3.26 mi

The Harbor Front Inn

· 4.3 Very Good · 217 reviews

Distinctive properties offering the warmth and attention no chain replicates.

  • Refuel with gourmet provisions suited to your event's extended schedule
  • Refresh in charming guest rooms designed for comfort and relaxation
  • Gather in cozy common spaces designed for conversation and celebration
Check Availability
Photo of The Menhaden Top rated
From $350 / night 3.27 mi

The Menhaden

· 4.8 Excellent · 142 reviews

Curated stays designed for guests who value consideration over corporate efficiency.

  • Discover thoughtfully designed lounges where conversation flows in unhurried comfort
  • Gather in intimate social spaces perfect for post-event celebrations
  • Retreat to designer rooms featuring curated artwork and plush bedding
Check Availability
Photo of Zey Hotel Highly rated
From $325 / night 3.45 mi

Zey Hotel

· 4.6 Excellent · 266 reviews

Distinctive hotels where accessibility and warmth replace cookie-cutter predictability every time.

  • Sink into thoughtfully appointed rooms designed for complete privacy and comfort
  • Admire distinctive architectural details that set this property apart completely
  • Sink into custom seating areas perfect for post-wedding celebration conversations
Check Availability
Photo of Sound View Greenport
From $233 / night 5.11 mi

Sound View Greenport

· 4.2 Very Good · 497 reviews

Owner-driven properties that understand what traveling grandparents actually need most often.

  • Retreat to peaceful accommodations offering premium linens and blackout window treatments
  • Appreciate thoughtfully curated design that reflects the area's unique character
  • Experience the unique character of individually styled guest room accommodations
Check Availability
Photo of The Shoals Suites and Slips Best value
From $202 / night 5.21 mi

The Shoals Suites and Slips

· 4.7 Excellent · 141 reviews

Local character and thoughtful service older travelers rarely find at chains anymore.

  • Indulge in elevated bath amenities that transform your routine into ritual
  • Relax in stylish common areas designed for conversation and connection
  • Wind down with premium wine selections from the personalized beverage menu
Check Availability
Photo of Sag Harbor Inn Highly rated
From $255 / night 9.09 mi

Sag Harbor Inn

· 4.7 Excellent · 498 reviews

Small-scale hospitality built to feel distinctive, welcoming, and genuinely local throughout.

  • Discover curated evening touches that reflect the inn's unique character
  • Celebrate special occasions in our elegantly appointed private dining room
  • Store wedding gifts and oversized items in secure designated areas
Check Availability

Booking 9+ rooms? Get group rates.

No upfront deposits Everyone pays separately Free coordinator room
Get Group Rates
Photo of Journey East Hampton
From $302 / night 19.46 mi

Journey East Hampton

· 4.5 Excellent · 69 reviews

Designed for travelers who expect friendly faces and consistent stays.

  • Store formal attire with convenient in-room space and hangers
  • Refill with infused water or hot chocolate between club events
  • Wrap yourself in fluffy white towels after morning shower routines
Free BreakfastGymWi-FiIndoor PoolLaundryEarly Check-In See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook
From $78 / night 24.02 mi

Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook

· 3.6 Good · 182 reviews

Straightforward lodging crafted for travelers who appreciate thoughtful, uncomplicated hospitality.

  • Park your motorcoach or RV in designated oversized spaces
  • Fill ice buckets easily for post-round beverages and refreshments
  • Recharge overnight in rooms with clean and fresh standard bedding
Free BreakfastPets OKWi-FiLaundryEarly Check-InIndoor Pool See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook
From $67 / night 24.4 mi

Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook

· 3.5 Good · 320 reviews

Consistent economy comfort built for attendees who expect more than bare minimum.

  • Refresh under curved shower rods that create extra elbow room
  • Print directions and itineraries for out-of-town wedding guests quickly
  • Relax in select rooms featuring upgraded seating ideal for guests
Free BreakfastBus ParkingWi-FiLaundryEarly Check-InIndoor PoolPets OK See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of The Hampton Maid
From $347 / night 24.98 mi

The Hampton Maid

· 4.7 Excellent · 83 reviews

Midscale comfort that remembers your name from Friday through Sunday checkout.

  • Enjoy complimentary hot tea selections available around the clock anytime
  • Select your ideal pillow firmness for customized head and neck support
  • Prepare event materials with business center printers and desktop access
Free BreakfastGymWi-FiIndoor PoolLaundryEarly Check-In See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Hampton Bays Hotel on Main
From $142 / night 26.81 mi

Hampton Bays Hotel on Main

· 3.0 Average

Personal service tailored for groups who appreciate genuine hospitality throughout.

  • Book small meeting spaces equipped with A/V for intimate gatherings
  • Enjoy pull-out sleeper sofas for flexible guest room arrangements
  • Trust the satisfaction guarantee to resolve any stay concern quickly
Free BreakfastGymWi-FiEarly Check-InLaundryIndoor Pool See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook
From $115 / night 26.91 mi

Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook

· 3.8 Good · 974 reviews

Known for delivering reliable comfort when the invitation matters most.

  • Recharge on premium mattresses with fluffy pillows between club gatherings
  • Reserve meeting rooms for family gatherings and pre-event coordination sessions
  • Gather guests in dedicated living space before the ceremony begins
Free BreakfastGymEarly Check-InLaundryPets OKIndoor PoolWi-FiBus Parking See all ›
Check Availability
Hotel offerings and amenities can change. Check the hotel page for up-to-date details.
Local Area Guide

Gardiner's Bay Country Club Travel Guide

We built this guide so your team doesn't have to figure it all out from a Google search. Neighborhoods, restaurants, game day logistics, local tips — it's all here.

Welcome to Gardiner's Bay Country Club on Shelter Island, New York. This guide is designed for players, coaches, families, and team coordinators heading to the club for golf events or outings. You'll find essential information to help you plan your trip, from understanding the local layout to knowing where to find amenities and gather between rounds. We'll cover arrival logistics, on-site facilities, nearby dining, and tips for making the most of your time on and around the island.

Section 01

Neighborhood Overview

Gardiner's Bay Country Club is situated on Shelter Island, a serene and picturesque island located between Long Island's North and South Forks, accessible primarily via ferry. The club is centrally located on the island, offering a tranquil environment away from the mainland hustle. Key access routes involve navigating local roads on Shelter Island itself, with the main ferries arriving from Greenport (North Fork) and Sag Harbor (South Fork). Driving times within the island are generally short, but ferry schedules and wait times can significantly impact your overall travel duration, especially during peak season. For those traveling by air, the closest major airports are Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP), followed by John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) and LaGuardia Airport (LGA) on the mainland, all of which require a ferry connection to reach Shelter Island. Rideshare services are available on the island, but their availability can be limited, making a personal vehicle or understanding ferry and taxi coordination crucial for timely arrivals and departures. Smart arrival tactics involve checking ferry schedules in advance, allowing ample buffer time for potential delays, and considering travel during off-peak ferry hours if your schedule permits.

Section 02

Where to Stay

Accommodations on Shelter Island are somewhat limited compared to the mainland Hamptons or North Fork, with a few inns and rental properties forming the primary lodging options. The nearest clusters of hotels are typically found in the mainland towns of Greenport and Sag Harbor, requiring a ferry ride to reach the club. Many groups and families participating in events at Gardiner's Bay Country Club opt to stay in these nearby mainland towns for a wider selection of amenities and lodging styles. When booking, consider proximity to the ferry terminals that serve Shelter Island. Demand for lodging spikes significantly during the summer months and around any major local events, so booking well in advance is highly recommended. Utilizing map filters for hotels and checking their distance to the respective ferry docks will be beneficial for planning your daily commute to the club.

Section 03

Quick-Plan Overview

Closest airport

Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP) · ~1 hour drive plus ferry

Parking/arrival

Arrive 30 minutes before tee time to account for ferry waits.

Walkable hangout

The 16-mile island offers scenic walks and charming village exploration.

Rainy-day fallback

Explore the historic shops and cafes in Shelter Island Heights village.

Regroup zone

The club's veranda or a local cafe in the Heights are ideal spots.

  • Closest airport: Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP) · ~1 hour drive plus ferry
  • Parking/arrival: Arrive 30 minutes before tee time to account for ferry waits.
  • Walkable hangout: The 16-mile island offers scenic walks and charming village exploration.
  • Rainy-day fallback: Explore the historic shops and cafes in Shelter Island Heights village.
  • Regroup zone: The club's veranda or a local cafe in the Heights are ideal spots.
Section 04

Round Day Flow

Check-In & Warm-Up

Plan to arrive at Gardiner's Bay Country Club at least 30-45 minutes before your scheduled tee time, especially if you need to coordinate with your group or utilize the practice facilities. Upon arrival, proceed to the pro shop or designated check-in area to confirm your registration, receive any necessary course information, and secure your assigned tee time. Familiarize yourself with the practice green and driving range to get a feel for the club's greens and turf conditions. It's advisable to have your clubs ready and be near the first tee a few minutes prior to your designated start time to ensure a smooth and timely beginning to your round.

Mid-Day Regroup

During your round, take advantage of the turn between the front and back nines for a brief regroup and refreshment. The club likely offers beverage carts or halfway house services for quick snacks and drinks to keep you energized. If your event includes a full lunch service, this would typically be scheduled post-round. For longer tournaments or multi-team events, consider designated shaded areas on the course or the club's veranda as informal spots for players and families to gather, share experiences, and relax between different stages of the competition.

Wrap-Up & Departure

After completing your final hole, head to the scoring area if required by the tournament format, or make your way to the clubhouse. The club's patio or dining area often serves as a central point for post-round socializing, scorecards, and casual meals. Allow ample time for this transition, as it's a chance to discuss the game and congratulate fellow participants. When departing, be mindful of the ferry schedules if you are heading back to the mainland, as they can have queues, particularly during peak times and weekends.

Check-In & Warm-Up

Plan to arrive at Gardiner's Bay Country Club at least 30-45 minutes before your scheduled tee time, especially if you need to coordinate with your group or utilize the practice facilities. Upon arrival, proceed to the pro shop or designated check-in area to confirm your registration, receive any necessary course information, and secure your assigned tee time. Familiarize yourself with the practice green and driving range to get a feel for the club's greens and turf conditions. It's advisable to have your clubs ready and be near the first tee a few minutes prior to your designated start time to ensure a smooth and timely beginning to your round.

Mid-Day Regroup

During your round, take advantage of the turn between the front and back nines for a brief regroup and refreshment. The club likely offers beverage carts or halfway house services for quick snacks and drinks to keep you energized. If your event includes a full lunch service, this would typically be scheduled post-round. For longer tournaments or multi-team events, consider designated shaded areas on the course or the club's veranda as informal spots for players and families to gather, share experiences, and relax between different stages of the competition.

Wrap-Up & Departure

After completing your final hole, head to the scoring area if required by the tournament format, or make your way to the clubhouse. The club's patio or dining area often serves as a central point for post-round socializing, scorecards, and casual meals. Allow ample time for this transition, as it's a chance to discuss the game and congratulate fellow participants. When departing, be mindful of the ferry schedules if you are heading back to the mainland, as they can have queues, particularly during peak times and weekends.

Section 05

Things to Do

Walkable

Shelter Island Heights Historic District

On site

Explore the charming historic district surrounding the country club, a Victorian-era village known for its unique architecture and peaceful ambiance. Wander along its quiet streets, admiring the well-preserved summer cottages and grander homes that reflect the island's past as a popular resort destination. The area offers a glimpse into a slower pace of life and provides opportunities for gentle strolls with scenic views, making it a pleasant diversion before or after your time on the golf course. It's an ideal spot for a leisurely walk to appreciate the local character.

Shelter Island Yacht Club

On site

While primarily a private club, the vicinity of the Shelter Island Yacht Club offers scenic waterfront views and a sense of the island's maritime heritage. Observing the boats docked and the club's architecture can be a pleasant experience for those walking the nearby public paths. It represents the active boating community that is integral to Shelter Island's identity and provides picturesque vistas of Gardiner's Bay and the surrounding waters, complementing the golf club's setting.

5–15 Minutes Away

Chequit Inn

0.5 mi

Experience the historic charm of the Chequit Inn, a quintessential island lodging establishment that often welcomes visitors for drinks or light fare on its veranda. Even if you're not staying here, its picturesque setting and colonial-style architecture make it a lovely spot to visit for a scenic break. The inn embodies the classic summer retreat atmosphere of Shelter Island and offers a taste of its refined, laid-back hospitality, perfect for a brief respite.

Ram Island Nature Preserve

4.2 mi

Discover the natural beauty of Shelter Island at Ram Island Nature Preserve, a tranquil sanctuary offering walking trails through woodlands and along the coastline. This preserve is ideal for nature lovers seeking a peaceful escape to observe local flora and fauna. The relatively easy terrain makes it accessible for a relaxing walk, providing a different perspective on the island's diverse environment beyond its manicured golf courses and villages.

Walkable

  • Shelter Island Heights Historic District — Explore the charming historic district surrounding the country club, a Victorian-era village known for its unique architecture and peaceful ambiance. Wander along its quiet streets, admiring the well-preserved summer cottages and grander homes that reflect the island's past as a popular resort destination. The area offers a glimpse into a slower pace of life and provides opportunities for gentle strolls with scenic views, making it a pleasant diversion before or after your time on the golf course. It's an ideal spot for a leisurely walk to appreciate the local character. On site
  • Shelter Island Yacht Club — While primarily a private club, the vicinity of the Shelter Island Yacht Club offers scenic waterfront views and a sense of the island's maritime heritage. Observing the boats docked and the club's architecture can be a pleasant experience for those walking the nearby public paths. It represents the active boating community that is integral to Shelter Island's identity and provides picturesque vistas of Gardiner's Bay and the surrounding waters, complementing the golf club's setting. On site

5–15 Minutes Away

  • Chequit Inn — Experience the historic charm of the Chequit Inn, a quintessential island lodging establishment that often welcomes visitors for drinks or light fare on its veranda. Even if you're not staying here, its picturesque setting and colonial-style architecture make it a lovely spot to visit for a scenic break. The inn embodies the classic summer retreat atmosphere of Shelter Island and offers a taste of its refined, laid-back hospitality, perfect for a brief respite. 0.5 mi
  • Ram Island Nature Preserve — Discover the natural beauty of Shelter Island at Ram Island Nature Preserve, a tranquil sanctuary offering walking trails through woodlands and along the coastline. This preserve is ideal for nature lovers seeking a peaceful escape to observe local flora and fauna. The relatively easy terrain makes it accessible for a relaxing walk, providing a different perspective on the island's diverse environment beyond its manicured golf courses and villages. 4.2 mi
Section 06

Food & Drink

Inside & Adjacent

Gardiner's Bay Country Club Restaurant

On site

The country club's own dining facilities offer a convenient and refined experience for members and their guests. Typically featuring a menu that balances classic fare with seasonal ingredients, it provides a comfortable setting for breakfast, lunch, or post-round drinks. Enjoying a meal here allows players and families to stay within the club's atmosphere, making it an easy choice for refueling without venturing far from the golf course, often with pleasant views.

The Ram's Head Inn

0.6 mi

The Ram's Head Inn offers a classic island dining experience with a focus on fresh, local ingredients, often served in a beautiful setting overlooking Coecles Harbor. Known for its sophisticated yet relaxed atmosphere, it's a popular spot for both intimate dinners and group gatherings. The menu frequently highlights seafood and seasonal produce, making it a delightful choice for those seeking quality cuisine in an elegant, waterfront environment.

Nearby Gathering Spots

Shelter Island Craft Brewery

1.5 mi

For a more casual vibe, Shelter Island Craft Brewery provides a relaxed setting to enjoy locally brewed beers and light pub fare. It's a great spot for groups to unwind after a day of activities, offering a communal atmosphere where players and families can share stories and enjoy the island's craft beverage scene. The brewery often features outdoor seating, perfect for soaking in the island's pleasant weather.

Marie Eiffel Market

0.5 mi

This charming market offers a delightful array of French-inspired pastries, sandwiches, salads, and coffee, making it an excellent option for a casual breakfast or lunch. It's a perfect spot for grabbing a quick bite to eat before heading to the course or for a relaxed mid-day break. The market's quaint ambiance and quality offerings provide a touch of European flair right on Shelter Island.

Local & Elevated Picks

American Hotel

0.4 mi

The American Hotel is a renowned establishment offering an upscale dining experience with a celebrated menu and an extensive wine list. Known for its refined atmosphere and exceptional service, it's an ideal choice for a special occasion meal or for those seeking a sophisticated culinary adventure. The hotel's classic decor and commitment to fine dining make it a standout destination on the island.

Dawn's Cheese & Provisions

2.1 mi

This specialty shop is a treasure trove for food lovers, offering an impressive selection of artisanal cheeses, charcuterie, gourmet sandwiches, and local provisions. It's an excellent place to assemble a picnic to enjoy at a scenic spot on the island or to pick up unique items to enhance your stay. The knowledgeable staff can help you select the perfect accompaniments for a relaxed meal or snack.

Inside & Adjacent

  • Gardiner's Bay Country Club Restaurant — The country club's own dining facilities offer a convenient and refined experience for members and their guests. Typically featuring a menu that balances classic fare with seasonal ingredients, it provides a comfortable setting for breakfast, lunch, or post-round drinks. Enjoying a meal here allows players and families to stay within the club's atmosphere, making it an easy choice for refueling without venturing far from the golf course, often with pleasant views. On site
  • The Ram's Head Inn — The Ram's Head Inn offers a classic island dining experience with a focus on fresh, local ingredients, often served in a beautiful setting overlooking Coecles Harbor. Known for its sophisticated yet relaxed atmosphere, it's a popular spot for both intimate dinners and group gatherings. The menu frequently highlights seafood and seasonal produce, making it a delightful choice for those seeking quality cuisine in an elegant, waterfront environment. 0.6 mi

Nearby Gathering Spots

  • Shelter Island Craft Brewery — For a more casual vibe, Shelter Island Craft Brewery provides a relaxed setting to enjoy locally brewed beers and light pub fare. It's a great spot for groups to unwind after a day of activities, offering a communal atmosphere where players and families can share stories and enjoy the island's craft beverage scene. The brewery often features outdoor seating, perfect for soaking in the island's pleasant weather. 1.5 mi
  • Marie Eiffel Market — This charming market offers a delightful array of French-inspired pastries, sandwiches, salads, and coffee, making it an excellent option for a casual breakfast or lunch. It's a perfect spot for grabbing a quick bite to eat before heading to the course or for a relaxed mid-day break. The market's quaint ambiance and quality offerings provide a touch of European flair right on Shelter Island. 0.5 mi

Local & Elevated Picks

  • American Hotel — The American Hotel is a renowned establishment offering an upscale dining experience with a celebrated menu and an extensive wine list. Known for its refined atmosphere and exceptional service, it's an ideal choice for a special occasion meal or for those seeking a sophisticated culinary adventure. The hotel's classic decor and commitment to fine dining make it a standout destination on the island. 0.4 mi
  • Dawn's Cheese & Provisions — This specialty shop is a treasure trove for food lovers, offering an impressive selection of artisanal cheeses, charcuterie, gourmet sandwiches, and local provisions. It's an excellent place to assemble a picnic to enjoy at a scenic spot on the island or to pick up unique items to enhance your stay. The knowledgeable staff can help you select the perfect accompaniments for a relaxed meal or snack. 2.1 mi
Section 07

Local Tips

Ferry schedules are critical: always check departure times and account for potential wait lines, especially on weekends.

Shelter Island is best explored by car: , though biking is popular for shorter distances in the summer.

Village shops and restaurants can have seasonal hours: , so confirm availability during your visit.

Rideshare options are limited: pre-booking a local taxi or using your own vehicle is recommended.

Many island residents enjoy a relaxed pace: factor this into planning for timely service at establishments.

Seasonal note: Shelter Island truly comes alive in the warmer months, with spring and summer bringing lush greenery and vibrant activity. This is the peak season for golf and outdoor recreation, drawing visitors to the country club and surrounding attractions. Fall offers a quieter, picturesque experience with beautiful foliage, while winter provides a tranquil escape with fewer crowds, though some seasonal businesses may be closed. Travel to the island is consistently managed by its ferry system, which operates year-round but may have reduced schedules in the off-season.

  • Ferry schedules are critical always check departure times and account for potential wait lines, especially on weekends.
  • Shelter Island is best explored by car , though biking is popular for shorter distances in the summer.
  • Village shops and restaurants can have seasonal hours , so confirm availability during your visit.
  • Rideshare options are limited pre-booking a local taxi or using your own vehicle is recommended.
  • Many island residents enjoy a relaxed pace factor this into planning for timely service at establishments.
  • Seasonal note: Shelter Island truly comes alive in the warmer months, with spring and summer bringing lush greenery and vibrant activity. This is the peak season for golf and outdoor recreation, drawing visitors to the country club and surrounding attractions. Fall offers a quieter, picturesque experience with beautiful foliage, while winter provides a tranquil escape with fewer crowds, though some seasonal businesses may be closed. Travel to the island is consistently managed by its ferry system, which operates year-round but may have reduced schedules in the off-season.
Section 08

Weather & Seasons

❄️

Winter

Winter on Shelter Island brings chilly temperatures, often ranging from the 20s to 40s Fahrenheit, with a chance of snow or freezing rain. Visitors should pack warm layers, including heavy coats, hats, gloves, and waterproof footwear. Outdoor activities like golf are generally not feasible, and daily schedules focus more on indoor pursuits and enjoying the quiet ambiance of the island.

🌱

Spring & early summer

Spring weather is often mild to cool, with temperatures gradually warming into the 50s and 60s Fahrenheit as summer approaches. Light jackets or sweaters are recommended for cooler mornings and evenings. This period is ideal for comfortable golf, as the landscape awakens with greenery, and the island becomes more active, though crowds are generally smaller than in mid-summer.

☀️

Mid-summer

Summers on Shelter Island are typically warm and humid, with daytime temperatures frequently in the 70s and 80s Fahrenheit, sometimes reaching into the 90s. Lightweight, breathable clothing is essential. Sun protection, including hats and sunscreen, is highly advised. Golf rounds can be enjoyed throughout the day, but staying hydrated is key, and afternoon thunderstorms are possible.

🍂

Fall season

The fall season brings crisp, cool air, with temperatures often ranging from the 50s to 70s Fahrenheit, accompanied by stunning foliage displays. Layers are again recommended, such as sweaters, light jackets, and comfortable walking shoes. This is a very pleasant time for golf and exploring the island's natural beauty, with fewer crowds than during peak summer.

📅

Rain & snow

Rain is possible year-round, though more frequent in spring and fall. Snowfall is generally moderate and occurs primarily in winter months. When encountering inclement weather, it's wise to have an umbrella and waterproof outer layers. Indoor activities, dining, and relaxing at your accommodation are good alternatives to outdoor pursuits, and check ferry operations for potential weather-related delays.

Winter

Winter on Shelter Island brings chilly temperatures, often ranging from the 20s to 40s Fahrenheit, with a chance of snow or freezing rain. Visitors should pack warm layers, including heavy coats, hats, gloves, and waterproof footwear. Outdoor activities like golf are generally not feasible, and daily schedules focus more on indoor pursuits and enjoying the quiet ambiance of the island.

Spring & early summer

Spring weather is often mild to cool, with temperatures gradually warming into the 50s and 60s Fahrenheit as summer approaches. Light jackets or sweaters are recommended for cooler mornings and evenings. This period is ideal for comfortable golf, as the landscape awakens with greenery, and the island becomes more active, though crowds are generally smaller than in mid-summer.

Mid-summer

Summers on Shelter Island are typically warm and humid, with daytime temperatures frequently in the 70s and 80s Fahrenheit, sometimes reaching into the 90s. Lightweight, breathable clothing is essential. Sun protection, including hats and sunscreen, is highly advised. Golf rounds can be enjoyed throughout the day, but staying hydrated is key, and afternoon thunderstorms are possible.

Fall season

The fall season brings crisp, cool air, with temperatures often ranging from the 50s to 70s Fahrenheit, accompanied by stunning foliage displays. Layers are again recommended, such as sweaters, light jackets, and comfortable walking shoes. This is a very pleasant time for golf and exploring the island's natural beauty, with fewer crowds than during peak summer.

Rain & snow

Rain is possible year-round, though more frequent in spring and fall. Snowfall is generally moderate and occurs primarily in winter months. When encountering inclement weather, it's wise to have an umbrella and waterproof outer layers. Indoor activities, dining, and relaxing at your accommodation are good alternatives to outdoor pursuits, and check ferry operations for potential weather-related delays.

Section 09

Venue Facts

Primary team

N/A (Country Club)

Neighborhood

Shelter Island Heights

Nearest airport

Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP)

Parking

On-site club parking

Walkable district

Shelter Island Heights village

Groceries & supplies

Local markets in the Heights or nearby Greenport.

Pharmacy

Limited on island; larger options in Greenport or Sag Harbor.

Urgent care

Closest options in Greenport or Southampton.

Downtime

Beaches, local shops, scenic drives around the island.

Pro tip

Book ferry tickets or arrive extra early during summer weekends.

Primary teamN/A (Country Club)
NeighborhoodShelter Island Heights
Nearest airportLong Island MacArthur Airport (ISP)
ParkingOn-site club parking
Walkable districtShelter Island Heights village
Groceries & suppliesLocal markets in the Heights or nearby Greenport.
PharmacyLimited on island; larger options in Greenport or Sag Harbor.
Urgent careClosest options in Greenport or Southampton.
DowntimeBeaches, local shops, scenic drives around the island.
Pro tipBook ferry tickets or arrive extra early during summer weekends.
Need to Know

Frequently Asked Questions

Real questions travelers ask before booking near Gardiner's Bay Country Club — answered with the specifics you actually need.

Questions Travelers Ask What people want to know before booking near Gardiner's Bay Country Club

What are the closest hotels to Gardiner's Bay Country Club?

The closest hotel to Gardiner's Bay Country Club is The Harbor Front Inn (3.26 mi, from $224/night) — a 7-minute drive. Other nearby options include The Menhaden (3.27 mi, from $350/night) and Zey Hotel (3.45 mi, from $325/night).

Which hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club are good for families?

Several hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club are well-suited for families. Journey East Hampton (19.46 mi, from $302/night), Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook (24.02 mi, from $78/night), and Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook (24.4 mi, from $67/night) all offer connecting rooms, a pool, complimentary breakfast, and on-site laundry. Journey East Hampton also has suites. Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook also has suites.

Which hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club are good for team or group travel?

Several hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club accommodate team and group travel. Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook (26.91 mi, from $115/night), Journey East Hampton (19.46 mi, from $302/night), and Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook (24.4 mi, from $67/night) all offer complimentary breakfast and on-site laundry. Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook also has meeting space and bus or oversized vehicle parking. Journey East Hampton also has meeting space. Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook also has bus or oversized vehicle parking.

Are there budget-friendly hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club?

Yes — Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook (24.02 mi, from $78/night), Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook (24.4 mi, from $67/night), and Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook (26.91 mi, from $115/night) are budget-friendly options near Gardiner's Bay Country Club, with free breakfast, free Wi-Fi, and free parking.

Which hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club are good for business travelers?

Several hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club cater to business travelers. Journey East Hampton (19.46 mi, from $302/night), The Hampton Maid (24.98 mi, from $347/night), and Hampton Bays Hotel on Main (26.81 mi, from $142/night) all offer free Wi-Fi, meeting space, and a fitness center.

Hotel Amenities & Features Pools, breakfast, pet policies, and more

Which hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club offer free breakfast?

Journey East Hampton (19.46 mi, from $302/night), Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook (24.02 mi, from $78/night), and Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook (24.4 mi, from $67/night) include complimentary breakfast.

Which hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club have an indoor pool?

Journey East Hampton (19.46 mi, from $302/night), Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook (24.02 mi, from $78/night), and Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook (24.4 mi, from $67/night) have an indoor pool available year-round.

Which hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club have a fitness center?

Journey East Hampton (19.46 mi, from $302/night), The Hampton Maid (24.98 mi, from $347/night), and Hampton Bays Hotel on Main (26.81 mi, from $142/night) have an on-site fitness center.

Which hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club are pet-friendly?

Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook (24.02 mi, from $78/night), Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook (24.4 mi, from $67/night), and Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook (26.91 mi, from $115/night) accept pets. Fee policies vary by property.

Which hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club offer free parking?

Journey East Hampton (19.46 mi, from $302/night), Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook (24.02 mi, from $78/night), and Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook (24.4 mi, from $67/night) offer complimentary parking.

Ready to book near Gardiner's Bay Country Club?

12 hotels to choose from. Lowest rate guarantee, flexible cancellation on most rooms, and a support team that gets sports travel.