Hotels4Teams
Hotels near Shelter Island Country Club

Hotels near Shelter Island Country Club

26 Sunnyside Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Quick dates:
Shelter Island Country Club
Check in – Check out
1 room

12 Hotels near Shelter Island Country Club

Multiple hotel sources, one search — rates you won't find on a single booking site.

Photo of The Harbor Front Inn Closest
From $224 / night 3.26 mi

The Harbor Front Inn

· 4.3 Very Good · 217 reviews

Independent properties where character shows in service, not square footage alone.

  • Sink into plush bedding after a full day of events
  • Relax in elegantly appointed guest rooms with distinctive period furnishings
  • Retreat to quiet corners with rich furnishings and personal touches
Check Availability
Photo of The Menhaden Top rated
From $350 / night 3.27 mi

The Menhaden

· 4.8 Excellent · 142 reviews

Owner-operated hotels built to feel distinct from the first step inside.

  • Enjoy complimentary area maps highlighting routes to exclusive club locations
  • Grab light bites and premium snacks from thoughtfully stocked areas
  • Sink into thoughtfully appointed rooms designed for complete privacy and comfort
Check Availability
Photo of Zey Hotel Highly rated
From $325 / night 3.45 mi

Zey Hotel

· 4.6 Excellent · 266 reviews

Character-driven stays designed for gatherings that refuse to follow a script.

  • Savor artisanal breakfast options that fuel your day without rushing you
  • Relax in stylish common areas designed for conversation and connection
  • Relax in sophisticated common areas with distinctive furnishings and ambiance
Check Availability
Photo of Sound View Greenport
From $233 / night 5.11 mi

Sound View Greenport

· 4.2 Very Good · 497 reviews

Boutique properties built around the independence extended family reunions require.

  • Celebrate special moments in beautifully appointed spaces with authentic ambiance
  • Experience the unique character of individually styled guest room accommodations
  • Gather in thoughtfully designed lounges with artisan coffee and cocktails
Check Availability
Photo of The Shoals Suites and Slips Best value
From $202 / night 5.21 mi

The Shoals Suites and Slips

· 4.7 Excellent · 141 reviews

Independent hotels where reunion groups find personality instead of corporate predictability.

  • Recharge in serene guest rooms featuring locally inspired design and plush bedding
  • Discover locally inspired décor that tells a story in every corner
  • Gather around the intimate fireside lounge after formal club events
Check Availability
Photo of Sag Harbor Inn Highly rated
From $255 / night 9.09 mi

Sag Harbor Inn

· 4.7 Excellent · 498 reviews

Owner-driven properties that offer warmth and individuality no chain can replicate.

  • Unwind in tastefully decorated lounges ideal for post-event group celebrations
  • Receive personalized directions and maps to nearby private club venues
  • Indulge in midnight refreshments after club dinners and special events
Check Availability

Booking 9+ rooms? Get group rates.

No upfront deposits Everyone pays separately Free coordinator room
Get Group Rates
Photo of Journey East Hampton
From $302 / night 19.46 mi

Journey East Hampton

· 4.5 Excellent · 69 reviews

Built for guests who appreciate genuine hospitality without pretense.

  • Relax in open-concept layouts designed for extra personal space
  • Rely on friendly staff for local dining and event recommendations
  • Gather around the signature community table in the lobby
Free BreakfastGymWi-FiIndoor PoolLaundryEarly Check-In See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook
From $78 / night 24.02 mi

Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook

· 3.6 Good · 182 reviews

Straightforward stays designed for travelers who value rest over resort extras.

  • Use convenient outdoor parking for easy load-in and load-out
  • Pour fresh coffee in the lobby before early tee times
  • Refresh in clean rooms with fresh bedding after event days
Free BreakfastPets OKWi-FiLaundryEarly Check-InIndoor Pool See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook
From $67 / night 24.4 mi

Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook

· 3.5 Good · 320 reviews

Reliable rooms designed for reunions that spill into the hallway.

  • Settle into modern Innovate room design for a restful stay
  • Access friendly front desk assistance at any hour day or night
  • Park RVs securely in designated oversized vehicle parking spots
Free BreakfastBus ParkingWi-FiLaundryEarly Check-InIndoor PoolPets OK See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of The Hampton Maid
From $347 / night 24.98 mi

The Hampton Maid

· 4.7 Excellent · 83 reviews

Designed for attendees who want dependable comfort during milestone celebrations.

  • Store garment bags and gifts using open-concept floor space
  • Enjoy consistent quality across every touchpoint during your club visit
  • Host impromptu conversations at the welcoming lobby community table
Free BreakfastGymWi-FiIndoor PoolLaundryEarly Check-In See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Hampton Bays Hotel on Main
From $150 / night 26.81 mi

Hampton Bays Hotel on Main

· 3.0 Average

Comfort that feels personal when the event demands your best presence.

  • Relax in flexible soft seating after the wedding reception
  • Recharge between ceremonies with quiet, comfortable guest room retreats
  • Stock up on travel essentials and toiletries at the Suite Shop
Free BreakfastGymWi-FiEarly Check-InLaundryIndoor Pool See all ›
Check Availability
Photo of Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook
From $115 / night 26.91 mi

Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook

· 3.8 Good · 974 reviews

Dependable stays positioned for attendees managing tight timelines around special occasions.

  • Settle into welcoming lobby seating between club activities and downtime
  • Pull in trailers or buses using designated oversized parking areas
  • Fuel morning rounds with hot coffee available around the clock
Free BreakfastGymEarly Check-InLaundryPets OKIndoor PoolWi-FiBus Parking See all ›
Check Availability
Hotel offerings and amenities can change. Check the hotel page for up-to-date details.
Local Area Guide

Shelter Island Country Club Travel Guide

We built this guide so your team doesn't have to figure it all out from a Google search. Neighborhoods, restaurants, game day logistics, local tips — it's all here.

Welcome to Shelter Island Country Club, your gateway to a classic Long Island golf experience. This guide is crafted for players, families, and groups looking to understand the rhythm of game days and make the most of their visit. We'll cover everything from arrival logistics and on-site amenities to nearby dining and essential local tips, ensuring your time here is seamless and enjoyable, whether you're here for a casual round or a competitive event.

Section 01

Neighborhood Overview

Shelter Island Country Club is nestled on the western side of Shelter Island, a tranquil oasis in the heart of New York's famed East End. The island itself is geographically unique, bordered by Gardiners Bay and Peconic Bay, accessible primarily by ferry from Sag Harbor and Greenport on Long Island. Navigating to the club involves scenic routes, often requiring a ferry crossing which adds to the destination's charm but necessitates careful planning for arrival times, especially during peak seasons or event days. The nearest major roads connect from the mainland via these ferry points, guiding you through picturesque, often winding, island roads. Parking is available directly at the club, with designated areas for members and guests. For those arriving without a vehicle, local taxi services and ride-sharing options are available, though their frequency can be less predictable than on the mainland. Planning your journey with ferry schedules in mind is crucial; aim to arrive at least 30-45 minutes before any scheduled tee time or event to account for ferry transit, island drives, and on-site check-in procedures. This proactive approach helps avoid any last-minute stress and allows you to settle in before your activity begins.

Section 02

Where to Stay

The immediate vicinity of Shelter Island Country Club offers a serene, primarily residential landscape interspersed with the natural beauty of the island. Lodging options are generally concentrated in the nearby Shelter Island Heights and slightly further afield in the charming towns of Sag Harbor and Greenport, which are just a ferry ride away. These areas feature a mix of boutique hotels, charming inns, and vacation rentals, catering to a relaxed vacationer or a group seeking a peaceful base. Given the island's nature, most visitors find it convenient to book accommodations that are either within walking distance or a short drive to the ferry terminals if they plan to explore beyond the island. Demand for lodging can surge around local tournaments, summer holidays, and special island events, making early booking a wise strategy. When searching for hotels, consider utilizing map filters to identify properties closest to the ferry docks or directly on Shelter Island itself, balancing convenience with the unique island atmosphere. Flexible dates can sometimes offer better rates, especially outside of peak summer weekends.

Section 03

Quick-Plan Overview

Getting There

Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP) is about a 75-minute drive, plus ferry time.

Arrival & Parking

Allow ample time for ferry crossings; arrive at the club 30-45 minutes early.

Tip

Stroll through historic Shelter Island Heights for local charm.

Food & Dining

Enjoy a quiet afternoon at a local cafe or explore the waterfront.

Food & Dining

The club's grill room or nearby restaurants serve as convenient regroup spots.

  • Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP) is about a 75-minute drive, plus ferry time.
  • Allow ample time for ferry crossings; arrive at the club 30-45 minutes early.
  • Stroll through historic Shelter Island Heights for local charm.
  • Enjoy a quiet afternoon at a local cafe or explore the waterfront.
  • The club's grill room or nearby restaurants serve as convenient regroup spots.
Section 04

Round Day Flow

Check-In & Warm-Up

As you arrive on Shelter Island, your first stop will be the country club's check-in area. Ensure you have your tee time or reservation confirmed. Familiarize yourself with the course layout and any specific club rules regarding play. Utilize the practice facilities, including the driving range and putting green, to get your swings warmed up and your short game dialed in. This pre-round preparation is key to a successful day on the course, allowing you to get a feel for the conditions and the speed of the greens.

Mid-Day Regroup

After your initial nine holes, you'll likely have an opportunity to take a break. The club's grill room or a nearby casual eatery provides an excellent spot to refuel with a quick lunch or snack. This is also a prime moment to discuss your front-nine performance with your playing partners, regroup mentally, and prepare for the back nine. Stay hydrated and check in with playing partners about pace of play if needed, ensuring a smooth continuation of your round.

Wrap-Up & Departure

Upon completing your round, make your way back to the clubhouse. Settle any outstanding balances or tournament fees and perhaps enjoy a post-round beverage at the bar. Take a moment to reflect on your game and perhaps plan your next visit. If departing by ferry, be mindful of the schedule, allowing enough time to drive to the terminal after your visit to the club, ensuring a relaxed end to your day on Shelter Island.

Check-In & Warm-Up

As you arrive on Shelter Island, your first stop will be the country club's check-in area. Ensure you have your tee time or reservation confirmed. Familiarize yourself with the course layout and any specific club rules regarding play. Utilize the practice facilities, including the driving range and putting green, to get your swings warmed up and your short game dialed in. This pre-round preparation is key to a successful day on the course, allowing you to get a feel for the conditions and the speed of the greens.

Mid-Day Regroup

After your initial nine holes, you'll likely have an opportunity to take a break. The club's grill room or a nearby casual eatery provides an excellent spot to refuel with a quick lunch or snack. This is also a prime moment to discuss your front-nine performance with your playing partners, regroup mentally, and prepare for the back nine. Stay hydrated and check in with playing partners about pace of play if needed, ensuring a smooth continuation of your round.

Wrap-Up & Departure

Upon completing your round, make your way back to the clubhouse. Settle any outstanding balances or tournament fees and perhaps enjoy a post-round beverage at the bar. Take a moment to reflect on your game and perhaps plan your next visit. If departing by ferry, be mindful of the schedule, allowing enough time to drive to the terminal after your visit to the club, ensuring a relaxed end to your day on Shelter Island.

Section 05

Things to Do

Walkable

Shelter Island Country Club Grounds

On site

Beyond the fairways, the country club itself offers a quintessential island experience. Take in the meticulously maintained grounds, enjoy a casual meal at the grill room, or simply relax on the patio overlooking the course. It's a perfect place to unwind after a round or for non-golfers in your group to soak in the peaceful atmosphere. The club often hosts local events and provides a relaxed, welcoming environment for all visitors.

Shelter Island Heights Historic District

0.3 mi

Stroll through the charming, historic summer cottage community of Shelter Island Heights, located just a short walk from the country club. Admire the Victorian architecture, tree-lined streets, and the unique character of this preserved enclave. The area offers a glimpse into the island's past as a vibrant summer resort. You'll find quiet pathways, local art galleries, and scenic viewpoints overlooking the water, perfect for a leisurely afternoon exploration.

5–15 Minutes Away

Coindre Hall Mansion

3.4 mi

Explore the grounds of Coindre Hall Mansion, a stunning French Renaissance-style estate perched on a hill overlooking the West Neck Bay. While primarily used for events, its picturesque architecture and waterfront setting make it a worthwhile destination for a scenic drive-by or a brief visit to appreciate its grandeur. The expansive lawns and gardens provide a beautiful backdrop for photos and a moment of historical reflection on the Gilded Age of Long Island's North Shore.

Mashomack Preserve

4.2 mi

Discover the natural beauty of Mashomack Preserve, a 2,374-acre nature sanctuary managed by The Nature Conservancy. Miles of marked trails wind through forests, meadows, and along the coastline, offering excellent opportunities for hiking, birdwatching, and experiencing the island's diverse ecosystems. It's a vital habitat for numerous bird species, including migratory shorebirds and raptors, making it a haven for nature enthusiasts and a peaceful escape into the wild.

Walkable

  • Shelter Island Country Club Grounds — Beyond the fairways, the country club itself offers a quintessential island experience. Take in the meticulously maintained grounds, enjoy a casual meal at the grill room, or simply relax on the patio overlooking the course. It's a perfect place to unwind after a round or for non-golfers in your group to soak in the peaceful atmosphere. The club often hosts local events and provides a relaxed, welcoming environment for all visitors. On site
  • Shelter Island Heights Historic District — Stroll through the charming, historic summer cottage community of Shelter Island Heights, located just a short walk from the country club. Admire the Victorian architecture, tree-lined streets, and the unique character of this preserved enclave. The area offers a glimpse into the island's past as a vibrant summer resort. You'll find quiet pathways, local art galleries, and scenic viewpoints overlooking the water, perfect for a leisurely afternoon exploration. 0.3 mi

5–15 Minutes Away

  • Coindre Hall Mansion — Explore the grounds of Coindre Hall Mansion, a stunning French Renaissance-style estate perched on a hill overlooking the West Neck Bay. While primarily used for events, its picturesque architecture and waterfront setting make it a worthwhile destination for a scenic drive-by or a brief visit to appreciate its grandeur. The expansive lawns and gardens provide a beautiful backdrop for photos and a moment of historical reflection on the Gilded Age of Long Island's North Shore. 3.4 mi
  • Mashomack Preserve — Discover the natural beauty of Mashomack Preserve, a 2,374-acre nature sanctuary managed by The Nature Conservancy. Miles of marked trails wind through forests, meadows, and along the coastline, offering excellent opportunities for hiking, birdwatching, and experiencing the island's diverse ecosystems. It's a vital habitat for numerous bird species, including migratory shorebirds and raptors, making it a haven for nature enthusiasts and a peaceful escape into the wild. 4.2 mi
Section 06

Food & Drink

Inside & Adjacent

Shelter Island Country Club Grill Room

On site

Enjoy casual American fare with a focus on fresh, local ingredients at the club's own Grill Room. Overlooking the picturesque greens, it’s the ideal spot for a post-round lunch, a light snack, or a refreshing drink. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, making it a convenient and pleasant option for players and guests seeking a bite without leaving the club grounds. Expect classic clubhouse dishes and friendly service.

The Chequit - Restaurant

0.9 mi

The Chequit offers a refined dining experience in a beautifully restored historic inn, just a short drive from the country club. Their restaurant focuses on seasonal menus featuring locally sourced seafood and produce, presented with elegant flair. It’s a wonderful choice for a more upscale meal, a special occasion, or simply to savor the flavors of the East End in a charming setting. Reservations are often recommended, especially during peak season.

Nearby Gathering Spots

Commander's Beach

1.5 mi

A casual, waterfront spot perfect for a relaxed meal with bay views. Commander's Beach offers a menu of American classics, often featuring seafood, and is known for its laid-back atmosphere. It's a great place to gather with friends or family after a day of activities, enjoy a drink as the sun sets, and soak in the island's tranquil ambiance. Outdoor seating is typically available, enhancing the waterfront dining experience.

Shelter Island Yacht Club - The Grill

1.9 mi

While a private club, the Shelter Island Yacht Club's grill area may offer dining options that are accessible to guests or during specific events, or is a good point of reference for the type of upscale, nautical dining that characterizes the island. It often provides a classic seaside menu, focusing on fresh catches and well-crafted cocktails. Check for any public access or event schedules if interested in experiencing this quintessential East End waterfront dining spot.

Local & Elevated Picks

Alure

1.1 mi

Alure offers a vibrant dining experience with a focus on contemporary American cuisine and a lively bar scene. Known for its creative cocktails and a menu that often includes inventive takes on seafood and land-based dishes, it's a popular spot for both locals and visitors. The ambiance is chic yet comfortable, making it suitable for a fun evening out or a sophisticated lunch. Consider their raw bar selections for a taste of local oysters and shellfish.

The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages - Restaurant

2.1 mi

The Pridwin's restaurant provides an elegant dining experience with stunning waterfront views, celebrating the best of Long Island's bounty. Their menu emphasizes fresh, seasonal ingredients, with a particular focus on seafood, prepared with refined culinary techniques. It's an ideal destination for a memorable meal, whether you're enjoying breakfast, lunch, or a romantic dinner. The sophisticated atmosphere and picturesque setting make it a standout choice on Shelter Island.

Inside & Adjacent

  • Shelter Island Country Club Grill Room — Enjoy casual American fare with a focus on fresh, local ingredients at the club's own Grill Room. Overlooking the picturesque greens, it’s the ideal spot for a post-round lunch, a light snack, or a refreshing drink. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, making it a convenient and pleasant option for players and guests seeking a bite without leaving the club grounds. Expect classic clubhouse dishes and friendly service. On site
  • The Chequit - Restaurant — The Chequit offers a refined dining experience in a beautifully restored historic inn, just a short drive from the country club. Their restaurant focuses on seasonal menus featuring locally sourced seafood and produce, presented with elegant flair. It’s a wonderful choice for a more upscale meal, a special occasion, or simply to savor the flavors of the East End in a charming setting. Reservations are often recommended, especially during peak season. 0.9 mi

Nearby Gathering Spots

  • Commander's Beach — A casual, waterfront spot perfect for a relaxed meal with bay views. Commander's Beach offers a menu of American classics, often featuring seafood, and is known for its laid-back atmosphere. It's a great place to gather with friends or family after a day of activities, enjoy a drink as the sun sets, and soak in the island's tranquil ambiance. Outdoor seating is typically available, enhancing the waterfront dining experience. 1.5 mi
  • Shelter Island Yacht Club - The Grill — While a private club, the Shelter Island Yacht Club's grill area may offer dining options that are accessible to guests or during specific events, or is a good point of reference for the type of upscale, nautical dining that characterizes the island. It often provides a classic seaside menu, focusing on fresh catches and well-crafted cocktails. Check for any public access or event schedules if interested in experiencing this quintessential East End waterfront dining spot. 1.9 mi

Local & Elevated Picks

  • Alure — Alure offers a vibrant dining experience with a focus on contemporary American cuisine and a lively bar scene. Known for its creative cocktails and a menu that often includes inventive takes on seafood and land-based dishes, it's a popular spot for both locals and visitors. The ambiance is chic yet comfortable, making it suitable for a fun evening out or a sophisticated lunch. Consider their raw bar selections for a taste of local oysters and shellfish. 1.1 mi
  • The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages - Restaurant — The Pridwin's restaurant provides an elegant dining experience with stunning waterfront views, celebrating the best of Long Island's bounty. Their menu emphasizes fresh, seasonal ingredients, with a particular focus on seafood, prepared with refined culinary techniques. It's an ideal destination for a memorable meal, whether you're enjoying breakfast, lunch, or a romantic dinner. The sophisticated atmosphere and picturesque setting make it a standout choice on Shelter Island. 2.1 mi
Section 07

Local Tips

Ferry schedules are critical: check times and potential delays, especially on weekends.

Island roads can be narrow and winding: drive cautiously and be aware of cyclists.

Cell service can be spotty in some areas: download maps or note directions offline.

Weekends and summer holidays see increased traffic and ferry waits: plan accordingly.

Pack insect repellent: , particularly for evenings or exploring nature preserves.

Seasonal note: Shelter Island offers a distinct charm throughout the year. Summers are lively and warm, with the island bustling with visitors enjoying the beaches and outdoor activities, making the country club a popular destination. Spring and fall bring milder weather, fewer crowds, and beautiful natural scenery, ideal for golf and quiet exploration. Winter is serene and quiet, with many seasonal businesses closed, offering a peaceful retreat for those seeking solitude, though club operations may be limited. The transition periods offer a pleasant balance of accessibility and tranquility for visiting the club.

  • Ferry schedules are critical check times and potential delays, especially on weekends.
  • Island roads can be narrow and winding drive cautiously and be aware of cyclists.
  • Cell service can be spotty in some areas download maps or note directions offline.
  • Weekends and summer holidays see increased traffic and ferry waits plan accordingly.
  • Pack insect repellent , particularly for evenings or exploring nature preserves.
  • Seasonal note: Shelter Island offers a distinct charm throughout the year. Summers are lively and warm, with the island bustling with visitors enjoying the beaches and outdoor activities, making the country club a popular destination. Spring and fall bring milder weather, fewer crowds, and beautiful natural scenery, ideal for golf and quiet exploration. Winter is serene and quiet, with many seasonal businesses closed, offering a peaceful retreat for those seeking solitude, though club operations may be limited. The transition periods offer a pleasant balance of accessibility and tranquility for visiting the club.
Section 08

Weather & Seasons

❄️

Winter

Winter on Shelter Island is cool to cold, with average temperatures ranging from the low 20s to the low 40s Fahrenheit. Expect brisk winds, especially near the water. Visitors should pack warm layers, including heavy coats, hats, and gloves. Outdoor activities like golf are less common, and playing conditions may be affected by frost or occasional snow. Waterproof footwear is advisable for any walking or travel.

🌱

Spring & early summer

Spring brings mild temperatures, gradually warming from the 40s into the 60s and 70s Fahrenheit. This is a beautiful time for golf as the island comes alive. Layers are key, with light jackets or sweaters needed for cooler mornings and evenings. Comfortable walking shoes are essential for exploring. As early summer arrives, temperatures climb into the 70s and low 80s, making it pleasant for outdoor activities but still requiring sun protection.

☀️

Mid-summer

July and August are the warmest months, with average highs in the mid-80s Fahrenheit, often with humidity. Pack light, breathable clothing like shorts, t-shirts, and sundresses. Sunscreen, hats, and sunglasses are essential. Golfing requires staying hydrated, and rounds are best played in the morning or late afternoon to avoid the peak heat. Evening temperatures are typically pleasant, allowing for comfortable outdoor dining.

🍂

Fall season

Autumn offers crisp, cool air, with temperatures gradually decreasing from the 70s in September to the 40s by November. It’s a prime season for golf with fewer crowds and beautiful foliage. A light to medium jacket or fleece is usually sufficient for daytime, with warmer layers recommended for cooler evenings. Comfortable walking shoes are still a must for exploring the island's trails and villages.

📅

Rain & snow

Rain is possible year-round, with heavier amounts often seen in fall and spring. Visitors should pack a compact umbrella and a waterproof jacket. Snowfall is most likely from December through March, though significant accumulations are not guaranteed every year. When snow does occur, it can temporarily impact travel on island roads and ferry services, though major routes are typically cleared. Be prepared for cooler, damp conditions during rainy spells.

Winter

Winter on Shelter Island is cool to cold, with average temperatures ranging from the low 20s to the low 40s Fahrenheit. Expect brisk winds, especially near the water. Visitors should pack warm layers, including heavy coats, hats, and gloves. Outdoor activities like golf are less common, and playing conditions may be affected by frost or occasional snow. Waterproof footwear is advisable for any walking or travel.

Spring & early summer

Spring brings mild temperatures, gradually warming from the 40s into the 60s and 70s Fahrenheit. This is a beautiful time for golf as the island comes alive. Layers are key, with light jackets or sweaters needed for cooler mornings and evenings. Comfortable walking shoes are essential for exploring. As early summer arrives, temperatures climb into the 70s and low 80s, making it pleasant for outdoor activities but still requiring sun protection.

Mid-summer

July and August are the warmest months, with average highs in the mid-80s Fahrenheit, often with humidity. Pack light, breathable clothing like shorts, t-shirts, and sundresses. Sunscreen, hats, and sunglasses are essential. Golfing requires staying hydrated, and rounds are best played in the morning or late afternoon to avoid the peak heat. Evening temperatures are typically pleasant, allowing for comfortable outdoor dining.

Fall season

Autumn offers crisp, cool air, with temperatures gradually decreasing from the 70s in September to the 40s by November. It’s a prime season for golf with fewer crowds and beautiful foliage. A light to medium jacket or fleece is usually sufficient for daytime, with warmer layers recommended for cooler evenings. Comfortable walking shoes are still a must for exploring the island's trails and villages.

Rain & snow

Rain is possible year-round, with heavier amounts often seen in fall and spring. Visitors should pack a compact umbrella and a waterproof jacket. Snowfall is most likely from December through March, though significant accumulations are not guaranteed every year. When snow does occur, it can temporarily impact travel on island roads and ferry services, though major routes are typically cleared. Be prepared for cooler, damp conditions during rainy spells.

Section 09

Venue Facts

Primary team

N/A (Country Club)

Neighborhood

Shelter Island Heights

Nearest airport

Long Island MacArthur (ISP)

Parking

On-site lots

Walkable district

Shelter Island Heights

Groceries & supplies

Local markets in Shelter Island Heights

Pharmacy

Available in Shelter Island Heights

Urgent care

Nearest facilities require ferry to mainland

Downtime

Exploring local shops, beaches, or waterfront parks

Pro tip

Book ferry tickets and tee times in advance, especially during peak season.

Primary teamN/A (Country Club)
NeighborhoodShelter Island Heights
Nearest airportLong Island MacArthur (ISP)
ParkingOn-site lots
Walkable districtShelter Island Heights
Groceries & suppliesLocal markets in Shelter Island Heights
PharmacyAvailable in Shelter Island Heights
Urgent careNearest facilities require ferry to mainland
DowntimeExploring local shops, beaches, or waterfront parks
Pro tipBook ferry tickets and tee times in advance, especially during peak season.
Need to Know

Frequently Asked Questions

Real questions travelers ask before booking near Shelter Island Country Club — answered with the specifics you actually need.

Questions Travelers Ask What people want to know before booking near Shelter Island Country Club

What are the closest hotels to Shelter Island Country Club?

The closest hotel to Shelter Island Country Club is The Harbor Front Inn (3.26 mi, from $224/night) — a 7-minute drive. Other nearby options include The Menhaden (3.27 mi, from $350/night) and Zey Hotel (3.45 mi, from $325/night).

Which hotels near Shelter Island Country Club are good for families?

Several hotels near Shelter Island Country Club are well-suited for families. Journey East Hampton (19.46 mi, from $302/night), Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook (24.02 mi, from $78/night), and Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook (24.4 mi, from $67/night) all offer connecting rooms, a pool, complimentary breakfast, and on-site laundry. Journey East Hampton also has suites. Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook also has suites.

Which hotels near Shelter Island Country Club are good for team or group travel?

Several hotels near Shelter Island Country Club accommodate team and group travel. Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook (26.91 mi, from $115/night), Journey East Hampton (19.46 mi, from $302/night), and Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook (24.4 mi, from $67/night) all offer complimentary breakfast and on-site laundry. Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook also has meeting space and bus or oversized vehicle parking. Journey East Hampton also has meeting space. Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook also has bus or oversized vehicle parking.

Are there budget-friendly hotels near Shelter Island Country Club?

Yes — Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook (24.02 mi, from $78/night), Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook (24.4 mi, from $67/night), and Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook (26.91 mi, from $115/night) are budget-friendly options near Shelter Island Country Club, with free breakfast, free Wi-Fi, and free parking.

Which hotels near Shelter Island Country Club are good for business travelers?

Several hotels near Shelter Island Country Club cater to business travelers. Journey East Hampton (19.46 mi, from $302/night), The Hampton Maid (24.98 mi, from $347/night), and Hampton Bays Hotel on Main (26.81 mi, from $150/night) all offer free Wi-Fi, meeting space, and a fitness center.

Hotel Amenities & Features Pools, breakfast, pet policies, and more

Which hotels near Shelter Island Country Club offer free breakfast?

Journey East Hampton (19.46 mi, from $302/night), Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook (24.02 mi, from $78/night), and Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook (24.4 mi, from $67/night) include complimentary breakfast.

Which hotels near Shelter Island Country Club have an indoor pool?

Journey East Hampton (19.46 mi, from $302/night), Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook (24.02 mi, from $78/night), and Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook (24.4 mi, from $67/night) have an indoor pool available year-round.

Which hotels near Shelter Island Country Club have a fitness center?

Journey East Hampton (19.46 mi, from $302/night), The Hampton Maid (24.98 mi, from $347/night), and Hampton Bays Hotel on Main (26.81 mi, from $150/night) have an on-site fitness center.

Which hotels near Shelter Island Country Club are pet-friendly?

Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook (24.02 mi, from $78/night), Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook (24.4 mi, from $67/night), and Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook (26.91 mi, from $115/night) accept pets. Fee policies vary by property.

Which hotels near Shelter Island Country Club offer free parking?

Journey East Hampton (19.46 mi, from $302/night), Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook (24.02 mi, from $78/night), and Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook (24.4 mi, from $67/night) offer complimentary parking.

Ready to book near Shelter Island Country Club?

12 hotels to choose from. Lowest rate guarantee, flexible cancellation on most rooms, and a support team that gets sports travel.